It's no surprise to us that the budget winter tyre, the Minerva Frostrack HP, performs very poorly. Even though it’s cheap, it does not offer good value for money. The Maxxis and Linglong are inexpensive, too, yet deliver more ability, but they fall short of the mid-field tyres – as does the Dunlop, which is a little better but needs to improve, especially in the wet.
Advertisement - Article continues below
Oddly for a winter tyre, the seventh-placed Falken sacrifices snow ability for wet and dry performance, while the Goodyear in sixth gets its priorities right, being at its best in the snow and wet. It’s a great winter tyre and isn’t far off the top five. The Michelin and Bridgestone tie for fourth and are similarly impressive in the same areas. The Hankook delivers in all the right areas and is great to drive, while the Pirelli is mainly outstanding and comes within an ace of matching the remarkable Continental.
Winner: ContinentalWinterContact TS870
Topping the table in all conditions – snow, wet and dry – the Conti wins in this size for the third time. It handles securely in all situations, and is refined and reasonably economical, too. A truly exceptional winter tyre.
Overall scores
1st
Continental
100%
2nd
Pirelli
99.8%
3rd
Hankook
99.4%
=4th
Bridgestone
99.3%
=4th
Michelin
99.3%
6th
Goodyear
98.9%
7th
Falken
98.6%
8th
Dunlop
97.3%
9th
Linglong
96.7%
10th
Maxxis
96.6%
11th
Minerva
93.0%
Price
1st
Maxxis
£73
2nd
Minerva
£89
3rd
Linglong
£90
4th
Falken
£105
5th
Bridgestone
£108
6th
Hankook
£115
7th
Dunlop
£119
8th
Pirelli
£132
9th
Continental
£135
10th
Goodyear
£138
11th
Michelin
£152
Snow braking
1st
Hankook
100
2nd
Bridgestone
99.6
3rd
Dunlop
99.3
4th
Michelin
98.9
5th
Continental
98.6
6th
Goodyear
98.2
7th
Pirelli
97.1
8th
Maxxis
96.8
9th
Linglong
96.3
10th
Falken
94.2
11th
Minerva
93.3
Snow traction
1st
Dunlop
100
2nd
Hankook
99.5
3rd
Michelin
99.2
4th
Goodyear
99.0
5th
Pirelli
96.9
6th
Bridgestone
96.6
7th
Linglong
95.1
8th
Maxxis
94.3
9th
Continental
94.2
10th
Falken
91.6
11th
Minerva
88.9
Snow handling
1st
Goodyear
100
=2nd
Hankook
99.5
=2nd
Pirelli
99.5
4th
Continental
99.0
5th
Michelin
98.9
6th
Linglong
98.6
7th
Bridgestone
98.3
9th
Dunlop
97.7
8th
Maxxis
97.7
10th
Falken
96.7
11th
Minerva
93.5
Wet braking
1st
Continental
100
2nd
Hankook
97.3
3rd
Pirelli
97.1
4th
Michelin
96.0
5th
Falken
95.7
6th
Bridgestone
94.8
=7th
Goodyear
94.3
=7th
Linglong
94.3
9th
Dunlop
91.9
10th
Maxxis
89.9
11th
Minerva
83.5
Wet handling
=1st
Continental
100
=1st
Pirelli
100
3rd
Falken
99.2
4th
Goodyear
98.8
5th
Michelin
98.5
6th
Bridgestone
98.5
7th
Hankook
98.1
8th
Linglong
96.5
9th
Dunlop
96.4
10th
Maxxis
96.2
11th
Minerva
91.6
Wet cornering
1st
Continental
100
2nd
Pirelli
99.4
3rd
Goodyear
99.3
4th
Bridgestone
97.8
5th
Michelin
97.4
6th
Falken
97.3
7th
Hankook
97.1
8th
Dunlop
96.2
9th
Maxxis
95.6
10th
Linglong
95.2
11th
Minerva
92.9
Straight aquaplaning
1st
Pirelli
100
2nd
Hankook
98.4
3rd
Goodyear
98.0
4th
Continental
96.6
5th
Michelin
94.4
6th
Bridgestone
93.5
7th
Falken
91.7
8th
Maxxis
91.2
9th
Dunlop
90.6
10th
Linglong
85.6
11th
Minerva
78.5
Curved aquaplaning
1st
Goodyear
100
2nd
Pirelli
98.9
3rd
Hankook
98.0
4th
Bridgestone
97.4
5th
Continental
96.6
6th
Dunlop
94.3
7th
Michelin
91.7
8th
Maxxis
91.4
9th
Falken
90.2
10th
Linglong
79.7
11th
Minerva
52.6
Dry braking
1st
Falken
100
2nd
Pirelli
98.4
3rd
Minerva
97.7
4th
Continental
97.3
5th
Hankook
96.7
6th
Michelin
96.4
=7th
Goodyear
96.2
=7th
Dunlop
96.2
9th
Linglong
96.0
10th
Maxxis
95.6
11th
Bridgestone
94.7
Dry handling
=1st
Bridgestone
100
=1st
Minerva
100
3rd
Hankook
99.8
4th
Continental
99.6
5th
Falken
99.5
6th
Linglong
99.3
7th
Maxxis
99.3
8th
Pirelli
99.0
9th
Michelin
99.0
10th
Dunlop
98.9
11th
Goodyear
98.6
Cabin noise
1st
Continental
100
=2nd
Bridgestone
99.9
=2nd
Linglong
99.9
=2nd
Falken
99.9
=5th
Goodyear
99.7
=5th
Minerva
99.7
=5th
Pirelli
99.7
8th
Dunlop
99.3
9th
Maxxis
99.1
10th
Michelin
99.0
11th
Hankook
98.8
Rolling resistance
1st
Michelin
100
2nd
Bridgestone
94.3
3rd
Continental
90.2
4th
Pirelli
89.6
5th
Dunlop
89.0
6th
Falken
88.7
7th
Hankook
88.3
8th
Goodyear
87.6
9th
Minerva
83.5
10th
Maxxis
80.4
11th
Linglong
77.7
Don't miss the best of Auto Express on Google! Make us a preferred source. Click here...