Skip advert
Advertisement

‘The Phantom has been a success, so why change a winning formula?’

Carmakers won’t abandon popular designs even if new models are anti-climactic, argues Graham Hope

One of the great privileges about this job is the opportunity to see new cars – or pictures of new cars – before they are presented to the wider world. The anticipation is always tangible as we open the images on our laptops and cast our eyes over the first official shots of an all-new model.

Advertisement - Article continues below

We had one of those moments this week, as the team huddled around a computer to check out the new Rolls-Royce Phantom. And the reaction as that first image opened up before our eyes? “Oh.”

Best luxury cars 2017

Because, let’s be honest here, it looks rather a lot like the last one, doesn’t it? It’s not the first time this has happened recently; the BMW 5 Series and Audi Q5 didn’t exactly reinvent the wheel, either.

Explaining Rolls-Royce’s position, designer Alex Innes admitted: “It’s similar to the old car in terms of lineage. We wanted the new car to be unmistakably ‘Phantom’ but modernise it.”

And you know what? I get that. The Phantom has been a big success for Rolls, so why mess with a winning formula? In many ways, creating a car that needs so little done to it in terms of a design update is mission accomplished for car companies. Customers will buy it regardless of how it looks (and what this impoverished commentator thinks).

So the rationale is understandable, and I acknowledge the Phantom is everything you expect a Rolls to be. But as car fans above all else, there’s always that little sense of anti-climax here in the Auto Express office when companies prove so restrained in updating their new models.  

On a slightly separate theme, and again speaking as a petrolhead, I was rather bemused at some of the hysterical headlines in the mainstream press that accompanied last week’s announcement of a petrol and diesel ‘ban’ in the United Kingdom by 2040. We bring you the real story here.

Do you disagree with Graham? Let us know in the comments section below.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Best saloon cars to buy in 2024
Best saloon cars

Best saloon cars to buy in 2024

Saloon cars may be less popular than they used to be, but there are still plenty of fantastic models to choose from
Best cars & vans
31 Oct 2024
Space galore in the new Rolls-Royce Phantom Goldfinger, perfect for a VIP oddjob
Rolls-Royce Phantom Goldfinger - front end with vintage Phantom

Space galore in the new Rolls-Royce Phantom Goldfinger, perfect for a VIP oddjob

The one-of-one creation's paint scheme has been precisely colour matched to Auric Goldfinger's 1937 Phantom III
News
25 Oct 2024
New Rolls-Royce Phantom Scintilla pays homage to the Spirit of Ecstasy
Rolls-Royce Phantom Scintilla - front 3/4 static

New Rolls-Royce Phantom Scintilla pays homage to the Spirit of Ecstasy

Rolls-Royce's Scintilla Private Collection take attention to detail to the max
News
16 Aug 2024
Top 10 best luxury cars to buy 2024
Best luxury cars - header image

Top 10 best luxury cars to buy 2024

Indulge yourself with our list of the best luxury cars on sale today
Best cars & vans
15 Jul 2024

Most Popular

Car Deal of the Day: fuel-sipping Toyota Yaris Cross with new tech for £257 per month
Toyota Yaris Cross - front tracking

Car Deal of the Day: fuel-sipping Toyota Yaris Cross with new tech for £257 per month

Toyota’s recently updated, highly efficient hybrid SUV is our Deal of the Day for 2 November
News
2 Nov 2024
Renault Scenic Iconic Long Range long-term test: head-to-head with the Ford Explorer
Renault Scenic long-termer - header

Renault Scenic Iconic Long Range long-term test: head-to-head with the Ford Explorer

First report: French SUV joins the fleet and takes on Ford’s new Explorer
Long-term tests
2 Nov 2024
Best car headlight bulbs 2024
Best car headlight bulbs - header image

Best car headlight bulbs 2024

Which car headlight bulbs will brighten your night?
Product group tests
1 Nov 2024