"We’re still waiting for a truly great small SUV"

Deputy editor John McIlroy looks at the mystery of small SUVs and reflects on the lack of daring and inventive features in their design

Small SUV opinion piece

Barely a week goes by, it seems, without one of our reviewers reporting back from the latest launch of a small SUV. 

I’ve been to three myself over the past month, picking apart the respective merits of the Citroen C3 Aircross, SEAT Arona and Hyundai Kona – and recently we put the first two of those up against the Kia Stonic on UK roads.

SEAT Arona vs Citroen C3 Cactus vs Kia Stonic triple test

I’ll leave you in suspense on the verdict, but suffice it to say that even the winner doesn’t manage to bag a full haul of five stars – our ultimate seal of approval.

That’s because the small SUV is a curious breed of vehicle whose appeal is still a mystery to many of us. You get a slightly elevated driving position, of course, although it’s nowhere near the commanding view that you’d enjoy from a full-size SUV.

There are funky image and personalisation options on many of the new models, too – but then, these are on many superminis already anyway.

And in the vast majority of cases it’s not as if you’re really gaining a lot in practicality. The best you can hope for is a very slightly larger boot and a teeny bit more headroom than the car’s supermini cousin. Which will, of course, be cheaper, because manufacturers know we’re willing to pay more for the image of an SUV, no matter how small it is. 

And yet we’re told, by car maker after car maker, that buyers can’t get enough of small SUVs, and that more are coming to showrooms near you over the next couple of years.

• Best crossovers and small SUVs on sale

We can but hope that they’re a bit more daring and inventive than what we’ve seen so far. We’re happy, of course, to recommend the best that’s out there right now – but we can’t help feeling that someone has yet to do a really proper job and define the small SUV as a genre. 

Do you think there is a stand out small SUV? Let us know in the comments below.

Recommended

'Gordon Murray is my British motor industry person of 2020'
Opinion

'Gordon Murray is my British motor industry person of 2020'

Mike Rutherford highlights his positive car industry stories of 2020
4 Jan 2021
'Citroen has changed the game and changed the lives of countless consumers'
Opinion

'Citroen has changed the game and changed the lives of countless consumers'

Mike Rutherford thinks the quirky new Citroen Ami is a true game-changing car
13 Dec 2020
'Power outages do nothing to inspire confidence in would-be EV buyers'
Opinion

'Power outages do nothing to inspire confidence in would-be EV buyers'

Mike Rutherford thinks the switch to an all-electric UK car market hasn't been thought through
29 Nov 2020
'MINI’s brand focus needs to rub off on BMW, too'
Opinion

'MINI’s brand focus needs to rub off on BMW, too'

BMW needs to regain its identity and should look to MINI for inspiration, says Steve Fowler
28 Oct 2020

Most Popular

BMW, Mercedes and Tesla owners could be at risk of higher insurance premiums
bmw x5 m50d tracking front
News

BMW, Mercedes and Tesla owners could be at risk of higher insurance premiums

Raw, uncapped insurance group rating data could be used by insurers to increase premiums on various high-end cars
19 Jan 2021
New 2021 Mercedes EQA electric crossover arrives with 302-mile range
Mercedes EQA - front
Mercedes EQA

New 2021 Mercedes EQA electric crossover arrives with 302-mile range

The new Mercedes EQA is a premium rival for the Volkswagen ID.3 and Kia e-Niro, with a maximum claimed range of 302 miles
20 Jan 2021
Best electric cars to buy 2021
Electric cars

Best electric cars to buy 2021

There are more electric cars than ever to choose from, so we've picked some of the best you can buy in the UK now
4 Jan 2021