"For new vehicles, depreciation remains a financial killer"

Trying to buy cars as appreciating assets is doomed to failure, says Mike Rutherford

Mike Opinion - Porsche

If I had a quid every time I was asked 'What new car should I buy?', I'd be about £37,000 richer by now. Listeners to my 1,000-plus radio phone-in programmes (I did one on the BBC only last week), viewers (there weren't many!) of the motoring advice show I hosted (badly!) on TV, plus readers of the car magazines and newspapers I began writing for in the early eighties haven't stopped asking... and I'm still answering.

Some folk don't take notice. Some do. My mate Bob is in the latter camp. Now he's sitting on - or in - his recently delivered, but now second-hand Porsche Macan that's currently worth more used than he paid new. Happy days! This model, like its stablemates the GT3 and GT4, resides in that 0.1 per cent group that makes it an appreciator, not a depreciator - during the early weeks and months of life, at least.

Fastest depreciating cars

Does this mean that private consumers should order and place deposits on future Porsches purely for financial investment? No way. As the company correctly points out, volatile and ever-changing market forces are at play here. Such things are way beyond the control of the manufacturer and everyone else come to that.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

"As always, our advice is to buy a Porsche to drive it," the firm says. And in a refreshing moment of honesty, it also reminds us that finance, insurance, servicing, garaging and other day-to-day car ownership expenses can quickly eat into any temporary profit a recently delivered 'new' (but technically second-hand) Porsche may generate for its owner.

Car depreciation: the models that hold their value best

Motorists are often in denial about the rate at which their new cars will (usually) slump or (unusually) increase in value. But my general rule is that over a typical one-to-three year/36,000 mile ownership period, every car will depreciate.

For the customer buying new vehicles, depreciation remains the number one financial killer - the most expensive thing he'll ever 'buy' during his motoring life. Over decades of driving, his depreciation price tags could easily total hundreds of thousands of pounds. If you remain determined to buy a new product, prior to selling it three years later at a profit, visit an estate agent rather than a motor trader. As an investor, what you require is a just-built freehold house with a gas supply, not a factory-fresh car running on petrol, diesel, or electricity.

Would you ever buy a car to make money out of it? Let us know in the comments below...




‘JLR’s very British approach: keep calm and carry on’

Editor-in-chief Steve Fowler praises Jaguar Land Rover on both its ability to handle a crisis
26 Mar 2020

'Car exhibitions are going through the most dramatic period of change in a generation'

With the changing car market, the government's petrol & diesel ban plus the unprecedented Coronavirus, the car exhibition industry is going through a …
22 Mar 2020

'We’ll always be here to bring you the best in car news'

In this extraordinary period of unprecedented action, fear not as Auto Express will always be here to deliver you the very best in car news
19 Mar 2020

Most Popular


MoT tests: six-month extension granted in wake of coronavirus

Transport Secretary announces six-month MoT extension for drivers whose cars are due MoT from 30 March, though vehicles must be kept “in roadworthy co…
25 Mar 2020
Speed limit to be cut to 60mph on M1
Tips & advice

Can I drive my car during the UK’s coronavirus lockdown?

The UK has been put on lockdown to help combat the spread of COVID-19, but does this mean you can’t drive your car anymore?
24 Mar 2020
Bentley Continental GT

Bentley’s built a horse-themed Continental GT Convertible

The bespoke Continental GT Convertible Equestrian Edition features tweed door panels, a walnut dash and gold “horse and rider” emblems
9 Mar 2020