'The £1m DfT emissions report tells us nothing we didn't already know'

As emissions remains a hot topic, editor Graham Hope is struggling to see the point of the Department for Transport's £1m report

Way back at the start of the year, I appeared in front of the Transport Select Committee discussing the Type Approval system. As I reported, the line of questioning was erratic, but it was generally accepted that the current emissions testing regime was wholly inadequate as the results it delivered were in no way reflective of what cars produced in real-world daily conditions.

Last week, a Department for Transport report concluded exactly the same thing, at a cost of £1m to the taxpayer. Great! Glad we cleared that up then.

Flippancy aside, there’s no denying emissions remain a hot topic. In the last week alone, we’ve seen Dutch MPs pass a motion to ban petrol and diesel car sales by 2025, to help reduce emissions. 

Emissions and efficiency testing rolling road

In the US, VW has offered to buy back cars affected in the Dieselgate scandal, while Mercedes owner Daimler has launched an investigation into how it spells out its cars’ emissions. And in Japan, Mitsubishi confessed to falsifying emissions tests data to improve fuel economy figures. 

Each story feeds public interest in the topic. So there’s an argument that the DfT probe, which found NOx levels can be six times as high in real-world use as in tests – and that car makers, VW apart, didn’t actually do anything wrong to optimise their cars for tests – was money well spent.

Independent tests reveal best and worst diesel cars for NOx emissions

I struggle to agree. Yes, it might have provided a degree of transparency for consumers as the industry seeks to restore consumer confidence.

But anyone who’s followed this story learned nothing new. To these eyes, all the report served to do was emphasise yet again how lax legislators and manufacturers have been in allowing a programme that isn’t fit for purpose to remain in place so long. 

The sooner there’s a new testing system the better – but we didn’t need a £1m investigation to tell us that.

Do you agree or disagree with Graham? Leave us a comment below...

Recommended

'This really is a great time to buy a new car'
Opinion dealership
Opinion

'This really is a great time to buy a new car'

Steve Fowler points out some great new car deals to be had in post-lockdown
14 Apr 2021
'Some traditions need to be abandoned, and working 9-5 is one of them'
Opinion commute
Opinion

'Some traditions need to be abandoned, and working 9-5 is one of them'

Britain needs to re-think its approach to commuting, according to Mike Rutherford
11 Apr 2021
'It's clear that lorry drivers deserve much-improved working conditions'
Truck
Opinion

'It's clear that lorry drivers deserve much-improved working conditions'

Mike Rutherford proposes some alternative options to help streamline British imports and exports
23 Jan 2021
'Gordon Murray is my British motor industry person of 2020'
Opinion

'Gordon Murray is my British motor industry person of 2020'

Mike Rutherford highlights his positive car industry stories of 2020
4 Jan 2021

Most Popular

Cupra Formentor vs Alfa Romeo Stelvio vs Porsche Macan
Cupra Formentor vs Alfa Romeo Stelvio vs Porsche Macan
Porsche Macan SUV

Cupra Formentor vs Alfa Romeo Stelvio vs Porsche Macan

Can the new Cupra Formentor stack up to the Alfa Romeo Stelvio and Porsche Macan in this sporty SUV battle?
17 Apr 2021
New 2021 Audi Q4 e-tron on sale now, priced from £40,750
Audi Q4 e-tron - front
Audi Q4 e-tron

New 2021 Audi Q4 e-tron on sale now, priced from £40,750

Two body styles, three powertrains and four trim-levels confirmed for Audi’s compact Q4 EV, including a 295bhp quattro option
15 Apr 2021
New Volkswagen Touareg R 2021 review
Volkswagen Touareg R - front
Volkswagen Touareg

New Volkswagen Touareg R 2021 review

Our verdict as the Volkswagen Touareg R performance SUV gets plug-in hybrid tech
16 Apr 2021