Independent tests reveal best and worst diesel cars for NOx emissions

Independent testing by Emissions Analytics mirrors the official RDE regulations scheduled for 2017 and grades models based on NOx

Emissions tests questioned

Independent nitrogen oxide emissions tests have revealed that just 30 per cent of diesel cars assessed would pass the new Real Driving Emissions (RDE) laws due to come into force from 2017.

Hundreds of Euro5 and Euro6 diesel, petrol and hybrid cars were tested and graded based on the grams per km of NOx they emitted. The newly published EQUA Air Quality Index by Emissions Analytics reveals just seven Euro6 diesels out of 62 received A grades (emitting up to 0.08g/km of NOx and inside the new legal limits).

A further three were ranked B - from 0.08 to 0.12 and inside the EU’s 2021 tolerances. Nine more scored C grades (0.12-0.18) – only good enough for the EU’s allowed limits up to 2019.

Most economical cars

Despite its well-publicised recent diesel emissions issues, the VW Group performed the best with the Audi A5, Skoda Superb, Volkswagen Passat and Scirocco some of those with A grades. The BMW 3 Series also scored an A grade while the 2 Series was ranked as a B.

The worst Euro 6 diesels tested were the Ssangyong Korando, Fiat 500X and a 2013 Audi A8, which all scored H grades. That’s equivalent to over 12 times the legal limit.

Petrol Euro 6 models performed much better with just one of 45 tested being outside the A to C grades. That was the three-cylinder 2015 Ford Focus which received an E grade emitting up to 0.50g/km – equivalent to the Euro 3 limit for diesels. All hybrid Euro 6 models passed with A grades, too.

What is the EQUA Air Quality Index?

The tests were conducted using the same equipment and methodology that EU type approval authorities will use from 2017 when the RDE system comes into force. The vehicles were tested within a few months of first registration with between 1,000 and 5,000 miles on the clock.

The EQUA Air Quality Index will now be continually updated as new models come to market and work alongside the RDE laws when they come into play in 2017.

Jaguar F-Type R - exhaust detail

Nick Molden, CEO and founder of Emissions Analytics, said: “There’s a great deal of confusion among car buyers on the subject of pollutant emissions, but we’re able to deliver impartial and precise information to help them buy better.

“We’re also looking forward to working with the industry as a whole to highlight the best vehicles available.”

Euro6 diesels best and worse NOx pollutants 

ManufacturerModelFuel TypeModel YearEngine size litresPowerTransmissionEqua AQ Index
AudiA5Diesel20142.0161ManualA
BMW3 SeriesDiesel20132.0184ManualA
SkodaSuperbDiesel20162.0148ManualA
VolkswagenGolf SVDiesel20152.0148AutomaticA
VolkswagenPassatDiesel20161.6118ManualA
VolkswagenSciroccoDiesel20152.0148ManualA
VolkswagenTouranDiesel20161.6108ManualA
        
AudiA8Diesel20133.0247AutomaticH
Fiat500XDiesel20151.6118ManualH
SsangyongKorandoDiesel20162.2176ManualH

What do you think of the Emissions Analytics test results? Let us know in the comments...

Recommended

Can I buy a car during the Covid-19 lockdown?
lockdown dealer
Coronavirus

Can I buy a car during the Covid-19 lockdown?

National lockdowns in all four parts of UK keep car dealers closed, but here’s how you can still buy a new or used car
23 Feb 2021
Covid-19: what it means for motorists and the car industry
Motorway
News

Covid-19: what it means for motorists and the car industry

Everything you need to know about how Covid-19 affects cars, motorists and the car industry in the UK
23 Feb 2021
January new car sales at lowest level since 1970
Ford Fiesta
News

January new car sales at lowest level since 1970

The first month of 2021 saw a 39.5 per cent decline in new car registrations year-on-year, with showroom closures stifling demand
4 Feb 2021
Hybrid and electric cars outsell diesels in Europe for the first time ever
News

Hybrid and electric cars outsell diesels in Europe for the first time ever

European registration figures show diesel cars playing second fiddle to the combined might of hybrids, plug-in hybrids, mild hybrids and electric cars
30 Oct 2020

Most Popular

'Genesis’s aim is to lure Jaguar Land Rover customers'
Genesis
Opinion

'Genesis’s aim is to lure Jaguar Land Rover customers'

Mike Rutherford thinks luxury brand Genesis could take sales away from Jaguar Land Rover when it lands in the UK
1 Mar 2021
Nissan Re-Leaf: the electric car with an emergency power bank
Nissan Re-Leaf - header
Nissan Leaf

Nissan Re-Leaf: the electric car with an emergency power bank

The Nissan Re-Leaf concept shows how a family EV could power disaster-relief operations
1 Mar 2021
New 2021 Volvo C40 joins brand’s electric car line-up
Volvo C40 - front
Volvo C40

New 2021 Volvo C40 joins brand’s electric car line-up

The new Volvo C40 Recharge will take on electric car rivals such as the Tesla Model 3 and forthcoming Audi Q4 e-tron
2 Mar 2021