Porsche Cayman S

We see how two-seater scores as an everyday car

  • Sublime on all roads and flatters every driver, more involving and rewarding than any rivaltactility and precision of the Cayman’s controls that set Cayman apart.
  • Excessive road noise harms the Porsche’s cruising ability. Seat itself is narrow across the shoulder, storage space is also the least generous here.

Seen in some quarters as a poor man’s 911, the Cayman S is a car for those who care more about driving than status. It doesn’t have the same high profile as its big brother, but the flat tailgate and rounded rear wheelarches manage to give the Porsche an athletic appearance.

There are two fewer seats inside and a pair of modestly proportioned load bays rather than one large one. Due to these compact dimensions, the Cayman weighs a third-of-a-tonne less than the M3.

As a result, it needs considerably less power for potent performance. The mid-mounted flat-six engine lacks the output of its V8 rivals, but look at the acceleration times – a match for all bar the BMW. And it certainly packs a punch above 5,500rpm, when the guttural growl develops into a raucous wail. The engine is mated to brilliant brakes and a slick gearbox which makes shifts a pleasure, and so the Porsche immediately comes across as a very satisfying car to drive.

That’s before you’ve even got to a corner, where the Cayman really shows its class. The steering isn’t as positive as the BMW’s, so initially it seems slightly vague, but it’s not long before the magic of this car hits you. It’s well balanced and gives excellent feedback, yet with the supple suspension, the Cayman S floats over rough surfaces. Refinement isn’t flawless, as the noise levels show, but the Porsche’s ability to match your mood is unrivalled here.

With the exception of the instrument dials, which overlap attractively, the interior layout is nothing special. What’s more, buyers don’t even get leather seats or climate control as standard. Nevertheless, the Cayman S is one of the most fluid and rewarding cars on sale today.


Price: Price: £44,080Model tested: Porsche Cayman SChart position: 1WHY: It’s great to drive, but we want to see if the Cayman S is as easy to live with as its practical rivals


Sleeker and far lighter than rivals, the Cayman S returned 22mpg and hit 27mpg on the motorway. It has the longest range, and annual fuel costs are at least £350 lower.


Too few Caymans are sold for our analysts to predict accurate residual figures. However, second-hand values should be close to the Boxster’s, at 52 per cent.


Porsche has a small UK dealer network. The two-year warranty is stingy, and while the engine’s position makes it hard to work on, £1,383 is a lot for three services.


It has the lowest CO2 output by over 40g/km, and a fine reputation for quality and reliability. But the Cayman S costs 20 pence per mile more to run than the Audi.

Most Popular

Appreciating cars: classic cars that go up in value
Appreciators: Renault 5

Appreciating cars: classic cars that go up in value

Looking to invest in a modern classic? Here are some cars destined to appreciate in value
4 May 2021
Genesis to launch in Europe this summer with line-up to rival Audi and Mercedes
Genesis G80 and GV80

Genesis to launch in Europe this summer with line-up to rival Audi and Mercedes

The Genesis G80 saloon and GV80 SUV will take on the Mercedes E-Class and GLE off-roader as the Korean luxury brand sets its stall out in Europe
4 May 2021
New 2022 Skoda Fabia grows in size and gets tech boost
Skoda Fabia - front
Skoda Fabia

New 2022 Skoda Fabia grows in size and gets tech boost

The new fourth-generation Skoda Fabia supermini is expected to hit UK showrooms early in 2022
4 May 2021