Skip advert
Advertisement

MINI Cooper D Clubman

Final report: Our estate signs off in style in a face-to-face with MINI’s hot hatch JCW flagship.

Pros
  • No other small car I have driven feels as grown up, well built or upmarket as the MINI Clubman. Add a superbly designed cabin to that refinement and this British-built estate is truly impressive. The layout of the dash is excellent, and I especially like the way the centre of the rev counter has a duplicate display to show speed, trip information or if the stop/start system is working.
Cons
  • Despite keeping the alloys clean and away from any damaging kerbs, the rims become pitted with flecks of road grime and brake dust. This makes it extremely hard to get the wheels looking spotless. Practicality will also fall short of the expectations of some buyers.
Find your MINI Clubman
Compare deals from trusted partners on this car and previous models.
Or are you looking to sell your car?
Value my car
Fast, no-nonsense car selling
Value my car

Good things always come to an end. After more than 15,000 miles of very happy motoring, we’ve said goodbye to our MINI Clubman Cooper D.

We certainly kept our MINI busy, though! As we reported in the last update the Clubman did two round- Europe trips, covering nearly 7,000 miles in two months, and there was no let-up in the hard work. As you can see above, the Cooper D also met up with our reigning hot hatch of the year, the John Cooper Works version of the MINI, at our Performance Car of the Year event in Wales.

And it’s a testament to the appeal of the Clubman that even after sampling the rapid hot hatch, I was more than happy to jump back into the Cooper D. It doesn’t have the power of the JCW, but the Clubman retains the engaging driving experience that makes MINIs so special.

The controls are wonderfully accurate, while the sharp steering, smooth throttle response and slick gearshift are a constant reminder of the depth of engineering quality. Our motoring has been largely trouble-free, too.

The £60 black bonnet stripes had to be removed after some acidic bird droppings left a permanent stain, although I thought the car looked better without them. And there was also a mystery handbrake fault, which allowed the car to roll dangerously down a hill.

Stephen James MINI in Ruxley, Kent, carried out our first service with little fuss as part of the MINI’s five-year £185 all-inclusive tlc maintenance pack. It also replaced all four brake discs under warranty – explaining there was a production fault with them – although we never did get to the bottom of whether this was connected to the one-off handbrake problem.

Another puzzle was solved, though – the onset of winter resulted in the stop/start system occasionally shutting down. A quick check of the handbook revealed the engine is sometimes deliberately left to run on at idle in the extreme cold. Nevertheless, during our time with the MINI, we averaged an impressive 44.9mpg.

The Clubman draws plenty of attention, too, and the eagle- eyed among you might even notice the larger 17-inch alloys on the car in the above action picture. The MINI wore these  for a tyre safety feature at the MIRA proving ground, where its punctured run-flats scored highly.

There’s no doubt about it – with its superb blend of fun, frugality  and refinement, our Clubman will be sorely missed.   
 

Extra Info

I only managed to prise the keys to the Clubman out of Owen’s hands twice – but it was easy to see why he loved it. There’s just enough performance to live up to its famous badge, while the long- distance economy is superb. A weekend trip from London to Wales went by in a flash, and cost half as much in fuel as most other long-termers.

Chris Thorp
Road Test Editor

Advertisement - Article continues below

On fleet since:
Price new:
Engine/power:
Options: Chili pack (£2,015), auto air-con (£230), folding and heated mirrors (£170/£45), multifunction wheel (£170), xenons (£465), anthracite roof lining (£115), stripes (£60), heated seats (£205), dark rear glass (£120), parking sensors (£215), Bluetooth (£505), voice control (£205), sat-nav (£1,395)
Trade-in-now:
Running costs:
Insurance grp/quote:
Mileage/mpg: 15,278/44.9mpg
Costs: None
Any problems?
Previous reports: 1,011 and 1,028
Insurance quote provided by AA
 

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Volkswagen Golf

Volkswagen Golf

RRP £24,625Avg. savings £3,189 off RRP*Used from £11,990
Vauxhall Corsa

Vauxhall Corsa

RRP £19,690Avg. savings £5,249 off RRP*Used from £14,350
Nissan Juke

Nissan Juke

RRP £19,785Avg. savings £4,614 off RRP*Used from £10,641
Skoda Kodiaq

Skoda Kodiaq

RRP £38,140Avg. savings £3,406 off RRP*Used from £10,195
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New Fiat Grande Panda goes on sale with tiny price and big ambition
Fiat Grande Panda La Prima - front cornering

New Fiat Grande Panda goes on sale with tiny price and big ambition

The newly crowned Auto Express Supermini of the Year is available in hybrid or pure-electric form, with the EV offering 199 miles of range
News
1 Sep 2025
Skoda Elroq and Enyaq get Electric Car Grant approval
Skoda Elroq - front cornering

Skoda Elroq and Enyaq get Electric Car Grant approval

Despite some models costing over the £37,000 threshold, Skoda has secured the government grant on its mid-size electric SUVs
News
2 Sep 2025
Car Deal of the Day: Enjoy Scandinavian style with the Volvo XC40 for just £296 a month
Volvo XC40 - front full width

Car Deal of the Day: Enjoy Scandinavian style with the Volvo XC40 for just £296 a month

Swedish company’s popular compact SUV is still effortlessly cool, and great value with our Deal of the Day for 31 August
News
31 Aug 2025