Skip advert
Advertisement

'High Insurance premiums are forcing owners to scrap their cars'

Mike Rutherford is stunned that car insurance premiums have risen by an average 61 per cent in the past 12 months

Opinion - scrap

The insurance industry urgently needs to take out a new policy – against itself. The reason? Just as the Volkswagen Group and a few other offending car manufacturers lost customers (some of them forever) who were cheated when purchasing diesel vehicles, a growing number of heinously greedy insurers are now losing motorists unable or unwilling to pay the absurdly high prices they’re being charged for their motor policies in 2023.

Advertisement - Article continues below

No doubt about it: countless drivers are now saying of the great insurance rip-off, enough is enough. But it’s not what they say, it’s what they do that matters.

Some are being forced to scrap cars on the grounds that the cost to insure them per year is not far off the value of the actual vehicles. And that’s madness.

Other motorists are slapping Statutory Off Road Notification (SORN) restrictions on their much-loved cars, locking them away uninsured in secure, private, alarmed garages and perhaps hoping to wheel them out again when the UK’s £20billion-per-year insurance business is forced by politicians or market forces (or both) to charge more reasonable prices.

Those who I consider to be the smartest real-world motorists are downgrading to more modestly priced and powered cars that sit in lower insurance groups.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Sadly, others are having to admit their motoring days are over because they can no longer pay the prices charged by insurers. How is that ‘progress’?

Another worrying by-product of the situation is the small but scary band of can’t-pay/won’t-pay drivers taking the illegal route of driving on public roads uninsured.

The above examples and other factors prove we’re in a rotten, car insurance industry-inspired mess. It’s motivated by sheer greed and designed to squeeze consumers until the pips squeak. Textbook stuff: an insurance sector pricing motorists out of the market and therefore reducing the size of its customer base. Firms are allowing once-loyal, lucrative clients to walk away and possibly never return. How dumb is that?

And how ironic that the unfit-for-purpose insurance industry now needs to seriously consider insuring itself – against the inevitable loss of countless customers, a reduction in the number of policies sold and, in turn, possible lost profits of millions of pounds.

Think I’m exaggerating? In a period of just 12 inflation-shattering months, quoted motor insurance premiums have risen by an average 61 per cent, with drivers in London paying 69.5 per cent more, those in the West Midlands suffering a 64.4 per cent hike, and South Easterners enduring a 64.2 per cent leap. At the same time wage rises – for the lucky ones that got them – were nearer six per cent! You do the maths.

Meanwhile, one of Britain’s best-known and most-respected national broadsheets reports that some Range Rovers have become “virtually impossible” to insure in certain parts of London. The paper reckons a typical 35-year-old female resident with six years’ driving experience is now being asked to pay £22,515 for annual cover. Worst value for money in modern motoring history? Probably.

Is car insurance too expensive? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section....

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Best GAP insurance 2026
Best GAP insurance 2026 - how we tested

Best GAP insurance 2026

Which website offers the best user experience and cover?
Product group tests
22 Jan 2026
What are Cat N and Cat S cars? Car insurance write-off categories explained
Crashed car

What are Cat N and Cat S cars? Car insurance write-off categories explained

If a car is written off by the insurance provider, it could be assigned Category A, B, S or N status, but what does this mean and how do write-off cla…
Tips & advice
25 Nov 2025
Cheapest cars to insure in the UK 2026
Cheapest cars to insure - header image

Cheapest cars to insure in the UK 2026

These are the cars with the lowest insurance group ratings in the UK today
Best cars & vans
6 Oct 2025
Insurance firms accused of secretly “taxing the poor” amidst heat from car finance scandal
Car insurance documents and car key

Insurance firms accused of secretly “taxing the poor” amidst heat from car finance scandal

Both car insurance and finance firms are under fire for covert practices that see consumers unknowingly paying more
News
2 Apr 2025

Most Popular

EV charging gets 10% cheaper and there’s more to come
Rapid charging Fiat 500

EV charging gets 10% cheaper and there’s more to come

Ultra-rapid chargers in December were five pence cheaper than they were in November for off-peak users, with a cut in VAT also on the cards
News
22 Jan 2026
Volvo EX60 2026 preview: extra large range and power for Volvo's medium SUV
Volvo EX60 - front

Volvo EX60 2026 preview: extra large range and power for Volvo's medium SUV

The new all-electric Volvo EX60 has some seriously impressive specs, and prices start from £56,360
News
21 Jan 2026
Volvo XC40, XC60 and XC90 SUVs will all get a revamp as brand hedges bets with hybrid
Volvo XC40 - front full width

Volvo XC40, XC60 and XC90 SUVs will all get a revamp as brand hedges bets with hybrid

The pragmatic decision will see Volvo building hybrids for as long as customers ask for them
News
22 Jan 2026

Find a car with the experts