Skip advert
Advertisement

Back-to-back tests are the best way to choose a new car. Trust me, I’m a car journalist

When choosing a new car, our deputy editor thinks the best way of comparing models on your shortlist is by testing them back-to-back

Back-to-back road tests - opinion

Well over a decade ago, on a cold winter’s morning, I took delivery of a then-new Ford Fiesta before heading to a familiar photo location with the Auto Express road test team. Here, I met two colleagues, who’d each brought a rival supermini. The result was a three-car group test which, if memory serves, the Ford won by a mile.

Advertisement - Article continues below

What I discovered that day has stayed with me ever since. Driving those three brand-new cars back to back, over the same roads and in identical conditions, demonstrated the value of these comparison tests. Threading the Fiesta down a stretch of twisting tarmac, before doing the same in a Volkswagen Polo and a Kia Rio, taught me more about car control, and how they compared dynamically, than you’d expect from 10 hours at a test track. 

Opening the boots to see what each could hold, assessing rear-seat space, trim quality and standard equipment; nothing compares to getting like-for-like rivals in the same place at the same time for a truly impartial appraisal.

Our processes have evolved, of course. When Auto Express was founded, there were no touchscreens, ADAS was a mere glint in tomorrow’s eye, and reliability was more important than economy. Today, we perform voice-control tests and economy runs – we even measure boot depths and load-lip heights.

Now, we’ve stepped it up a notch, bringing together five of the most important family SUVs. Evaluating each in areas such as performance and driving, interior, design and technology, practicality and efficiency, we’ve gone through every aspect with a fine-tooth comb to crown the best car in this class. 

It’s something we’ll be doing more of in the future. Along with the very latest news and reviews, these independent and in-depth tests are Auto Express’s bread and butter; we’ve set the benchmark since 1988, and will continue to do so for years to come.

Get even more from Auto Express, follow our channels...
• Google
• Reddit 
• Whatsapp

Skip advert
Advertisement
Richard Ingram deputy editor Auto Express
Deputy editor

Richard has been part of the team for over a decade. During this time he has covered a huge amount of news and reviews for Auto Express, as well as being the face of Carbuyer and DrivingElectric on Youtube. In his current role as deputy editor, he is now responsible for keeping our content flowing and managing our team of talented writers.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

How to import a car: shipping, taxes and other costs explained
Imported Mazda rolling off a ship

How to import a car: shipping, taxes and other costs explained

Seen a car abroad that’s tempting you? Don’t let its location put you off - importing a car is more straightforward than you might think, but you need…
Tips & advice
11 Nov 2026
I’d never buy a car without checking its engine, and neither should you
Jordan engine opinion

I’d never buy a car without checking its engine, and neither should you

News editor, Jordan Katsianis says the devil is in the detail when you pick an engine in your new car.
Opinion
5 Nov 2026
Car depreciation explained: future residual values and how they’re calculated
Car dealership forecourt

Car depreciation explained: future residual values and how they’re calculated

What is car depreciation, how does it work and what can you do to minimise it on your car? We reveal all in our guide…
Tips & advice
29 Oct 2026
8 used car nightmares: the pitfalls buyers must avoid at all costs
Modified cars

8 used car nightmares: the pitfalls buyers must avoid at all costs

We’re here to help you avoid your dream car purchase turning into a nightmare with some words of warning.
Features
22 Oct 2026

Most Popular

New Audi A3: posh hatch won’t go EV but will get stunning design
Audi A3 render (watermarked) - front

New Audi A3: posh hatch won’t go EV but will get stunning design

There’s a new Audi A3 on the way and our exclusive images preview how the hatchback could look
News
17 Nov 2026
New Jaecoo 7 Luxury+ arrives with improved EV range and an AWD option
New Jaecoo 7 Luxury+ - front 3_4

New Jaecoo 7 Luxury+ arrives with improved EV range and an AWD option

The new Luxury+ trim for the Jaecoo comes with more equipment, a bigger plug-in hybrid battery and the option of all-wheel drive
News
18 Nov 2026
New Geely Monjaro EM-i is a PHEV that barely needs its engine
Geely Monjaro EM i - front charging

New Geely Monjaro EM-i is a PHEV that barely needs its engine

Geely has provided further details of its new Monjaro, which will have one of the longest plug-in hybrid EV ranges when it goes on sale
News
17 Nov 2026

Find a car with the experts