Porsche accused of altering Cayman R emission test for UK market

Pulling away in second gear said to have produced reduced CO2 readings for Porsche Cayman R, leading to lower tax bills for owners

Porsche Cayman R rear cornering

Porsche has been caught up in emissions test irregularities, after a tribunal heard it altered the UK test regime the Cayman R was subjected to. 

The company is understood to have started the Cayman R’s UK carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions test in second gear as opposed to first, with the result being that it produced less CO2 when assessed. The previous-generation Cayman R’s UK emissions test result was 221g/km (grams per kilometre) or CO2 yet, in the rest of Europe, it was rated at 228g/km. 

Best sports cars to buy now

The lower reading means UK examples of the Cayman R sat in band K instead of L of the road tax regime at the time. While the associated cost of those bands has changed over the years with inflation, the jump between them has always been the sharpest of any on the road tax table. Band K is currently £315 a year and band L stands at £540.

The claims were inadvertently uncovered by the legal team of a Cayman R owner, who sued Porsche in 2011 over an alleged defect with his vehicle. While that claim was settled by Porsche, the owner approached the company for more information related to the car’s emissions, and also asked the Vehicle Certification Agency (VCA) - the organisation charged with certifying vehicle emissions in the UK - for relevant data.

WLTP and RDE real-world emissions tests explained

Both Porsche and the VCA initially refused to disclose the information but, at a Freedom of Information tribunal, a Porsche representative said the differences between the Cayman R’s UK CO2 emissions and its European ones were due to “different taxation regimes” between the UK and the rest of the continent.

The VCA said Porsche had explained the Cayman R’s discrepancy “was confirmed as being in line with the appropriate type approval legislation”. Porsche told the Times, which uncovered news of the test irregularities, that it was unable to comment on the issue due to it being “linked to ongoing legal proceedings”.

Get the full story on the VW emissions scandal here...

Recommended

Porsche 718 Cayman GTS 4.0: long-term test review
Porsche 718 Cayman GTS 4.0: long-term test review - first report header
Porsche Cayman

Porsche 718 Cayman GTS 4.0: long-term test review

First report: The bright green Porsche 718 Cayman GTS 4.0 sports car has quickly won our hearts and minds
9 Sep 2021
Best used sports cars 2021
Best used sports cars - header
Best cars & vans

Best used sports cars 2021

Our top used sports cars for those looking for a fun but usable second-hand car
18 Aug 2021
Best performance cars 2021
Best performance cars - header
Best cars & vans

Best performance cars 2021

We run through the top ten performance cars on sale in the UK right now
20 Jul 2021
Best sports cars 2021
Best Sports cars - header
Mazda MX-5

Best sports cars 2021

From the McLaren 720S to Mazda MX-5, these are the 10 sports cars that we think are the best on sale
3 Jun 2021

Most Popular

New Ford Focus unveiled with 2021 facelift and tech updates
Ford Focus ST Line - front
Ford Focus Hatchback

New Ford Focus unveiled with 2021 facelift and tech updates

Ford has given the Focus hatchback a refresh for 2021, with a new design and an improved infotainment suite
14 Oct 2021
Nissan launches combined PCP finance deal for electric car and charger
Nissan Leaf
Nissan

Nissan launches combined PCP finance deal for electric car and charger

The unusual new offer is available on the Nissan Leaf and e-NV200 van – and it includes the cost of installing the wallbox charger at your home
13 Oct 2021
Friends reunited: buying back a Porsche 911
Porsche 911
Porsche 911 Coupe

Friends reunited: buying back a Porsche 911

How perfect timing led a Porsche 911 fanatic to buy back his old car
14 Oct 2021