SUVs- Yeti vs iX35
They have off-road styling, but can two-wheel drive help crossovers achieve a supermini thirst for fuel?
Off-road-inspired looks and elevated bodies give the latest generation of crossover models plenty of rugged appeal. Yet their two-wheel-drive transmissions provide the kind of fuel economy a genuine 4x4 could only dream of.
In 2.0-litre TDI trim, the Yeti promises to deliver a reasonable 52.3mpg. Its rival here, the ix35 2.0 CRDi Style, isn’t far behind, claiming 51.4mpg combined.
Neither figure is especially competitive with the rest of the models in our mileage marathon. But would this be evident in our 60mph test?
The Yeti SE comes with cruise control as standard, and on our test loop, this made maintaining a constant speed easy. Only top-spec Premium versions of the ix35 are fitted with the labour-saving kit, though, so keeping our Style example cruising at a consistent pace demanded more concentration.
First to come to a halt was the Skoda, which stopped after 200.5 miles. The Hyundai didn’t continue for a much longer, covering 205.1 miles on its £20 of fuel. There was a mere 1.3mpg separating the two SUVs – only the cabriolets were more closely matched – and impressively, both had bettered their manufacturer’s official combined claim.
The ix35 recorded a 5.7mpg improvement over its official figure, averaging 58.6mpg in our test. The Skoda posted 55.8mpg – up 3.5mpg on the brochure figure. But the Yeti wasn’t the least frugal car overall. It edged ahead of the Peugeot 5008, travelling 2.6 miles further.
Neither SUV had the advantage of stop-start, so on our urban circuit, they struggled. The Hyundai was held back by its shorter gearing, and pulled higher revs at 30mph and 40mph – hitting its returns.
Both contenders have a long way to go before they can challenge the cars at the top of our ranking. So it willbe interesting to see if Skoda introduces an eco-friendly Greenline version of the Yeti.
For now, our test suggests the ix35 is the SUV that will keep you away from pumps longest. The fact it drives well, and has Hyundai’s best interior ever, only adds to the appeal.
In this review
- 1IntroductionWe run 12 of the UK's most economical cars dry to see which travels furthest on the average fill up
- 2How we did it...Calculating accurate mpg figures requires precision testing. Here’s the story of how our assessments were carried out
- 3Superminis- Ibiza vs C3There’s a clear eco winner as SEAT and Citroen come together – but is our champ a compromised choice?
- 4Family hatches- Golf vs FocusBig sellers with big eco credentials, but the Ford and VW proved to be real long-distance runners
- 5Cabrios- 207 cc vs 500cIt’s a close finish here as our open-top pair proves that fun in the sun needn’t come at a cost
- 6Compact Execs- A4 vs 3-SeriesThese saloons blend luxury and driver appeal – but we had a clear winner in the eco stakes
- 7MPVs- 5008 vs Grand ScenicPeople carriers aren’t the most obvious fuel sippers, but one performed very creditably here
- 8SUVs- Yeti vs iX35 - currently readingThey have off-road styling, but can two-wheel drive help crossovers achieve a supermini thirst for fuel?
- 9The Results...We’ve crunched all the numbers to bring you a league table of our economy winners and losers