Skip advert
Advertisement

MPVs- 5008 vs Grand Scenic

People carriers aren’t the most obvious fuel sippers, but one performed very creditably here

With boxy shapes and extra seating to carry around, you wouldn’t expect proper people carriers to perform well here. Their bluff designs are brilliantly practical, but can seriously dent fuel consumption, so our economy test promised to expose MPVs as thirsty machines. Or did our duo find the perfect blend of practicality and efficiency?

Advertisement - Article continues below

This pairing is an all-French affair, as we put the Renault Grand Scenic up against Peugeot’s new 5008. The former is fitted with a set of low-rolling resistance tyres to improve economy, while the latter boasts a drag coefficient of only 0.29Cd, making it one of the most streamlined models in the class.

It also has another trick up its sleeve, in the form of its Electronic Gearbox Control (EGC) set-up. This automated manual system promises reduced consumption compared to the manual version.

It all adds up to what should be one of the most closely fought battles in our test. Both cars have CO2 emissions of 135g/km and combined economy of 55.4mpg, so how did they cope on our constant 60mph loop? With £20 of diesel in the tank, the 1.6-litre HDi Peugeot was first to run out of juice. It covered 197.9 miles, which translates to 55.1mpg – only 0.3mpg short of the official combined claim, but the worst result for any of the cars in our economy marathon.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Used - available now

Jazz

2020 Honda

Jazz

30,389 milesManualPetrol1.3L

Cash £9,995
View Jazz
I-PACE

2023 Jaguar

I-PACE

37,565 milesAutomaticElectric

Cash £23,995
View I-PACE
Qashqai

2016 Nissan

Qashqai

61,900 milesAutomaticPetrol1.2L

Cash £8,980
View Qashqai
Juke

2015 Nissan

Juke

57,010 milesAutomaticPetrol1.6L

Cash £8,980
View Juke

With the 5008 parked at the side of the track, we expected the Grand Scenic to peter out close by – so how much longer could the 1.5-litre dCi continue?

Advertisement - Article continues below

It eventually came to a halt 27.9 miles later, after covering an impressive 225.8 miles. That works out at 62.9mpg, placing the big MPV a creditable sixth in our overall standings – and ahead of the tiny Fiat 500C.

Neither of these cars is fitted with stop-start technology or tricks such as regenerative braking to cut fuel consumption, so our urban drive revealed few dynamic surprises. However, with an extra 5bhp over its Renault rival, the 110bhp Peugeot felt punchier on our city test.

Its automated gearbox made tackling our town route a breeze for the driver, too, although the 5008’s gearshifts are hard to anticipate. They’re also slow and jerky if you don’t lift off the throttle, so we’d give it a miss. The EGC box comes with cheap column-mounted shift paddles, and costs an extra £500, so we’d go for the cheaper manual version instead.

Yes, it’s more polluting, but the rewards from behind the wheel are worth the penalty in our book. The more economical Grand Scenic would be our choice here, though.

Our results suggest that it promises superior fuel economy, with minimal compromise when it comesto performance. The Grand Scenic also saw off the 5008 in a recent Auto Express twin test, so the Renault would seem to be the wiser option on every level.
 

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Volkswagen Golf

Volkswagen Golf

RRP £24,625Avg. savings £2,261 off RRP*Used from £12,800
Skoda Kodiaq

Skoda Kodiaq

RRP £38,140Avg. savings £3,019 off RRP*Used from £13,895
Dacia Spring

Dacia Spring

RRP £14,995Avg. savings £1,676 off RRP*
Kia Sportage

Kia Sportage

RRP £28,065Avg. savings £2,233 off RRP*Used from £15,297
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Leapmotor B05 family hatch on route to the UK with sub-£30k price and 400-mile range
Leapmotor badge

Leapmotor B05 family hatch on route to the UK with sub-£30k price and 400-mile range

The Stellantis-backed brand will launch a Volkswagen ID.3-rivalling small car with almost 20 per cent more range
News
23 Apr 2025
Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering
Opinion - Shanghai Auto Show

Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering

This new brand of cars might have battery tech on their side, but European buyers want much more than that
Opinion
25 Apr 2025
New Renault Clio prepares for launch: And it's not an EV
Renault Clio Mk6 (camouflaged) - front 3/4 tracking

New Renault Clio prepares for launch: And it's not an EV

The Clio isn’t going anywhere despite the reemergence of the Renault 5
News
22 Apr 2025