Car group tests

Kia Optima vs Audi & Mazda rivals

Kia has given its Optima saloon catwalk looks as part of a facelift. Does it have what it takes to beat rivals from Mazda and Audi?

Kia Optima vs rivals

The past 12 months have seen a resurgence for the saloon car sector. With new models introduced by a variety of makers, it’s meant the established brands have had to raise their game to remain competitive.

One such model is the Kia Optima. It was introduced in 2011, but now it’s been given a facelift to boost its appeal. As well as a revised nose featuring foglamps borrowed from the Pro_cee’d GT hot hatch, the four-door gets an updated interior with new seats. The changes don’t end there, either, because Kia has also worked on the Optima’s refinement in a concerted effort to make the car the quietest and most comfortable saloon in its class.

But is that enough for the Optima to stay competitive? To find out, we’ve lined up two new arrivals in the shape of Mazda’s 3 Fastback and Audi’s A3 Saloon. The former mixes efficiency and performance thanks to its light weight and punchy 2.2-litre diesel, while the Audi delivers a premium feel and new levels of efficiency due to the introduction of the frugal 1.6 TDI diesel that debuted earlier this year in the VW Golf BlueMotion and SEAT Leon Ecomotive.

• Kia Optima review

• Audi A3 saloon review 

• Mazda 3 Fastback review 

Has Kia done enough to fend off the newcomers – or does the Optima come up short?

Click on the links above to read each review, and read on to find out the full verdict. 

Head-to-head

Load space 

The Kia is the largest car here, so it’s no surprise that it’s got the biggest luggage space. At 505 litres, this is 80 litres up on the Audi’s, and 86 litres ahead of the Mazda’s.

The latter both come with seat-release levers in the boot, but neither features self-folding chairs. In the Audi, the releases are on the seat shoulder, right where they’re needed, so you can fold the seats in no time compared to its rivals.

Saloon styling

While the Audi is clearly a saloon, the other two models could be mistaken for hatchbacks, due to their steeply raked rear screens. The clue is a lack of back wiper, although the Optima could do with one, because the screen soon gets obscured by rain when you’re stopped in traffic.

Fuel efficiency

All three cars feature stop-start, and the Kia has a handy timer showing you how long the engine has been stopped for. In practice, the Mazda remained idle longest, although high temperatures meant all were using their air-con, which cut the length of time the stop-start system worked for.

Verdict

1st place: Mazda 3 Fastback

With its combination of punchy performance and lightweight efficiency, the Mazda 3 Fastback is the best compact saloon on the market. It’s not the most spacious car, but it’s big enough for most needs, plus it has a long list of standard kit, a good-quality interior and handling that will put a smile on your face. Add in competitive pricing, and the Fastback is a class leader.

2nd place: Audi A3 saloon 

You pay a premium for the A3 Saloon and it’s not as well equipped as either rival in this test, but the superb cabin means this Audi has a real feelgood factor. While the 1.6-litre TDI diesel isn’t the most responsive engine around, it makes up for this with low running costs, while the sharp chassis and electronic diff mean this small saloon is entertaining to drive.

3rd place: Kia Optima

The updates haven’t gone far enough to make the Optima competitive against its newer rivals here. The saloon looks great, has plenty of space in the back and is loaded with kit, but the uninspiring driving experience and relatively high running costs count against it. We also think Kia should offer its latest safety kit as an option on lower-spec models.

Figures 

 Mazda 3 Fastback 2.2D Sport NavAudi A3 Saloon 1.6 TDI SportKia Optima 1.7 CRDi 2
On the road price/total as tested£22,545/£22,285£22,925/£27,095£22,895/£23,405
Residual value (after 3yrs/36,000)£9,041/40.1%£12,081/52.7%£9,181/40.1%
Depreciation£13,504£10,844£13,714
Annual tax liability std/higher rate£720/£1,439£686/£1,372£959/£1,919
Annual fuel cost (12k/20k miles)£1,728/£2,881£1,674/£2,789£ 1,697/£ 2,828
Ins. group/quote/road tax band/co24/£340/B/£2016/£327/A/£017/£451/D/£110
Servicing costs£499 (3yrs/37,500)£16p/m (3yrs/60k)£329 (3yrs)
    
Length/wheelbase4,585/2,700mm4,456/2,637mm4,845/2,795mm
Height/width1,450/1,795mm1,416/1,796mm1,455/1,830mm
Engine4cyl in-line/2,191cc4cyl in-line/1,598cc4cyl in-line/1,685cc
Peak power/revs148/4,500 bhp/rpm109/3,200 bhp/rpm134/4,000 bhp/rpm
Peak torque/revs380/1,800 Nm/rpm250/1.500 Nm/rpm325/2,000 Nm/rpm
Transmission6-spd man/fwd6-spd man/fwd6-spd man/fwd
Fuel tank capacity/spare wheel51 litres/space saver50 litres/space saver70 litres/full alloy
Boot capacity419 litres425 litres505 litres
Kerbweight/payload/towing weight1,383/452/1,500kg1,270/550/1,500kg1,559/491/1,300kg
Turning circle/drag coefficient11.3 metres/0.26Cd10.7 metres/N/A10.9 metres/N/A
Basic warranty (miles)/recovery3yrs (60,000)/3yrs3yrs (60,000)/3yrs7yrs (100,000)/1yr
Service intervals/UK dealers12.5k miles (1yr)/107Variable/12120k miles (1yr)/170
Driver Power manufacturer/dealer pos8th/17th^12th/23rd^7th/10th^
Euro NCAP: Adult/child/ped./stars93/86/65/5*95/87/74/5*N/A
    
0-60/30-70mph8.2/8.2 secs9.9/10.3 secs9.7/9.2 secs
30-50mph in 3rd/4th3.2/5.0 secs4.6/7.0 secs4.5/6.9 secs
50-70mph in 5th/6th6.5/9.1 secs9.9/13.7 secs7.6/11.5 secs
Top speed/rpm at 70mph132mph/1,800rpm126mph/1,800rpm125mph/2,100rpm
Braking 70-0/60-0/30-0mph51.8/38.4/9.6m49.7/36.2/10.1m49.2/35.3/10.7m
Noise outside/idle/30/70mph66/44/63/72dB67/48/63/69dB62/45/60/71dB
Auto Express econ (miles/mpl)/range42.8/9.4/480 miles44.2/9.7/486 miles43.6/9.6/671 miles
Govt urban/extra-urban/combined60.1/80.7/72.4mpg62.8/83.1/74.3mpg49.6/64.2/57.6mpg
Govt urban/extra-urban/combined15.9/17.7/13.2mpl13.8/18.3/16.3mpl10.9/14.1/12.7mpl
Actual/claimed CO2/tax bracket177/104g/km/16%171/99g/km/15%174/128g/km/21%
    
Airbags/Isofix/park sensors/cameraSix/yes/yes/noSeven/y/£345/£275Six/yes/yes/yes
Automatic box/stability/cruise controlNo/yes/yes£1,480/yes/£225£1,555/yes/yes
Climate control/leather/heated seatsYes/£1,000/yesYes/£1,115/£260Yes/yes/yes
Metallic paint/xenons/tyre monitor£540/yes/no£525/£1,250/yes£510/no/no
Sat-nav/USB/DAB radio/BluetoothYes/yes/yes/yes£495/yes/yes/yesYes/yes/£250/yes

Most Popular

New 2021 Vauxhall Astra teased for the first time
Vauxhall Astra teaser 1
Vauxhall Astra

New 2021 Vauxhall Astra teased for the first time

The new Vauxhall Astra will get electrified powertrains and a more premium image
8 Jun 2021
‘Our switch to electric will soon make driving manual cars a lost art'
Gearknob
Opinion

‘Our switch to electric will soon make driving manual cars a lost art'

Want to drive a manual car? You need to take your test in a manual car. So what happens once all driving-school cars are automatic EVs?
8 Jun 2021
New Vauxhall Astra prototype review
Vauxhall Astra prototype - front
Vauxhall Astra

New Vauxhall Astra prototype review

A new Vauxhall Astra is on the way and we've driven a prototype ahead of its official arrival
14 Jun 2021
'The hydrogen underdog disruptor is back in town'
Toyota Mirai opinion
Opinion

'The hydrogen underdog disruptor is back in town'

Mike Rutherford says hydrogen-powered cars could still be a frequent sight on UK roads
13 Jun 2021
UN report highlights ethical problems with electric cars
Electric car charging
News

UN report highlights ethical problems with electric cars

Analysis reveals lithium refining takes 65 per cent of Chilean region’s water, while 40,000 child miners dig for cobalt in DRC
14 Jun 2021
New Porsche Macan facelift prototype review
Porsche Macan prototype - front
Porsche Macan

New Porsche Macan facelift prototype review

We get behind the wheel of a prototype version of the facelifted Porsche Macan SUV
13 Jun 2021
Illegal car modification hotspots revealed
Volkswagen Polo exhaust
News

Illegal car modification hotspots revealed

Gloucestershire has the highest proportion of illegal car modifications, with altered number plates the most common breach
14 Jun 2021
'Factories are at a standstill because they can’t get the parts to finish cars'
Car manufacturing
Opinion

'Factories are at a standstill because they can’t get the parts to finish cars'

Steve Fowler points out the fresh issues facing global car manufacturing
9 Jun 2021
Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport vs Cupra Leon 300
Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport vs Cupra Leon 300
Car group tests

Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport vs Cupra Leon 300

The capable Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport goes up against its new Cupra Leon 300 sibling in this hot hatch battle
12 Jun 2021
New Nissan Qashqai production begins in Sunderland
Nissan Qashqai - front static
News

New Nissan Qashqai production begins in Sunderland

Nissan will offer every school child in the North East of England a place on the Nissan Skills Foundation course to mark 35 years of manufacturing in …
14 Jun 2021
New 2021 Volkswagen T7 Multivan replaces Caravelle
Volkswagen T7 Multivan - front
Volkswagen Caravelle

New 2021 Volkswagen T7 Multivan replaces Caravelle

The Volkswagen T7 Multivan MPV switches to the MQB platform and adds plug-in hybrid technology
10 Jun 2021
New 2021 Tesla Model S Plaid launched with 1,006bhp
Tesla Model S facelift - front
Tesla Model S

New 2021 Tesla Model S Plaid launched with 1,006bhp

Range-topping version of the Tesla Model S officially unveiled, with a sprint time of 0-60mph in less than two seconds
10 Jun 2021
New hydrogen-powered Land Rover Defender prototype in development
Land Rover Defender
Land Rover Defender

New hydrogen-powered Land Rover Defender prototype in development

The Land Rover Defender FCEV prototype will be assessed for off-road and long-range zero-emission motoring
14 Jun 2021
New Skoda Enyaq iV 2021 review
Skoda Enyaq iV 80 Sportline - front
Skoda Enyaq

New Skoda Enyaq iV 2021 review

The new Skoda Enyaq iV is the Czech firm’s first bespoke electric car and we've tested the full range on UK roads
10 Jun 2021