Mazda CX-3 vs Nissan Juke & Renault Captur

Mazda rather lagged behind the curve with the launch of its new CX-3 compact crossover, arriving years after cars like the Nissan Juke and Renault Captur had firmly established the class. 

• Best crossovers on the market

Yet the public’s appetite for trendy crossovers is showing no sign of decline, and Mazda is renowned for delivering off-roaders that look good, are great to drive, offer frugal running costs and boast plenty of family-friendly practicality.

36

The larger CX-5 SUV is an Auto Express favourite, and with the CX-3, Mazda is hoping it’s applied that winning formula to a smaller model.

• Best SUVs to buy now

We’ve lined up two of its toughest rivals in the form of the stylish Juke and the practical Captur to give Mazda’s new model a stern test.

36

All three boast downsized diesel engines that claim strong efficiency. Plus, the cars offer something different to a conventional five-door supermini, as they focus on design and personalisation – thus enabling buyers to make their compact crossovers stand out from the crowd.

Can the CX-3 hit the ground running and go straight to the top of this highly competitive class? Read on to find out.

36

• Mazda CX-3 review

Used - available now

2017 Ford

Focus ST

90,200 milesManualDiesel2.0L

Cash £9,500

View Focus ST

2019 Kia

Stinger GT

72,000 milesAutomaticPetrol2.0L

Cash £17,500

View Stinger GT

2016 MINI

3-Door Hatch

39,000 milesManualPetrol1.2L

Cash £9,000

View 3-Door Hatch

2020 Land Rover

Discovery

60,543 milesAutomaticDiesel2.0L

Cash £22,500

View Discovery

• Nissan Juke review

• Renault Captur review

Click the links above to read individual reviews, and scroll down to see which compact crossover is crowned winner of this test...

Head-to-head

Personalisation

36

Customisation is king in the crossover sector, but the Mazda loses ground to the Nissan and Renault, with less scope to personalise the car. However, the CX-3 looks the sharpest from the outside and feels more premium; particularly inside, where the Sport Nav trim gets contrasting upholstery.

Versatility

36

These cars are meant to offer practicality on par with a supermini. While the Captur and the CX-3 serve up even more usability, with lots of room inside and a commanding driving position, the Juke’s packaging is poor. No matter where you’re sat, it feels compromised.

Equipment

36

The Mazda might be pricey, but its kit count is the best of our trio. It’s the only one that gets LED headlamps and autonomous braking as standard, with upmarket features like heated seats and a reversing camera among the range of equipment.

Verdict

1st place: Mazda CX-3 

36

Its price might seem steep next to rivals, but the CX-3 justifies the gap thanks to its mix of great design, class and driving dynamics. It can’t match the Captur for versatility, but when it comes to mixing fashion-led styling with practicality, it’s more convincing than the ageing Juke. Of these high-spec models, it’s the CX-3’s kit list that’s the most appealing, too, with lots of safety features.

2nd place: Renault Captur 

36

Quality isn’t the Captur’s strongest suit, but with a functional interior sporting a few touches of design flair, it has just enough charm to relegate the Juke to third place. The spongy edge to how the Renault drives ensures it can’t compete with its rivals on the road, though. Instead, strong fuel economy and low running costs mean it appeals to the head more than the heart. 

3rd place: Nissan Juke

36

In this company, the Nissan feels outclassed dynamically and practically. The Juke’s mid-life update improved its good points further, but the poor packaging remains, which hampers its chances against fresher cars like the CX-3 and Captur. It’s still fun to drive, but factor in the car’s hefty price tag with Nissan’s styling add-ons and it makes the CX-3 look like good value.

Other options in this category…

Suzuki Vitara 1.6 DDiS SZ5

Price: £19,499 Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl, 118bhp

It might not be as stylish, but with more power and 106g/km CO2 emissions, the Vitara makes financial sense. The SZ5 model gets lots of kit, including keyless go, adaptive cruise, a reversing cam and sat-nav.

Citroen C4 Cactus Flair BlueHDi 100

Price: £18,090 Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl, 98bhp

If you want to stand out from the crowd, the Citroen C4 Cactus fits the bill. Its quirky design boasts Airbumps to help avoid car park door dings; it’s less powerful, but 92g/km CO2 emissions make for low running costs.

Key specs: