Skip advert
Advertisement

“Volkswagen, SEAT and Skoda cars are just too similar”

Mike Rutherford thinks Volkswagen, SEAT and Skoda need to target different audiences if they are to be successful in the future

Opinion - VW and Skoda

Officially they’re Volkswagen Group products. But I think of them as cars from the House of VACSS – VW, Audi, Cupra, SEAT and Skoda – of Germany, Spain and the Czech Republic.   

These are vehicles I know very well. My first car in the late seventies was a beige Beetle (AGC 829G). The first brand-new car I saved up for and bought myself was a Mk1 Golf (OYX 518Y) in ’82. Since then I must have driven hundreds of VWs, and I still own three. I’ve also pedalled 100-plus Audis – including, in 1988, a pig of an Audi 80 company car that kept breaking down. But on a happier note, I was truly honoured to be among the first in the world to pilot the little-known Le Mans (search online for Auto Express Audi Le Mans Quattro) on a closed US circuit in 2004 – years before its official launch as the R8.

I’ve had my fair share of Cupras and their SEAT siblings, too. And after completing a mega-mileage cross-Europe drive in a System Porsche-engined Ibiza on the eve of the Spanish firm’s mid-eighties UK launch, I immediately bought one because I was so impressed with it and its low showroom price. As for Skodas, what’s not to like about the brand, build quality and generally friendly dealer network?

Advertisement - Article continues below
Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

But the Volkswagen Group has for years had a problem with three, possibly four, out of five of these brands. Audi is fine, the strongest of the bunch and the most profitable per unit sold (just over 10 per cent). Because it’s so young and still trying to establish itself, the jury’s out on whether the Cupra marque is fine too. But at least it’s trying to be different to the Volkswagen, SEAT and Skoda brands. The problem with the latter three is that they’re just too similar.

Living with them day to day, there is absolutely nothing between them. The badge I like most (solely for nostalgic reasons) is VW’s. I approve of SEAT targeting young, fun motorists – but what’s the point when they’re still being charged VW-like prices they can’t, as youngsters, afford? Which member of the trio enjoys the best quality? Skoda, I’d argue. Also, it’s the most profitable of the three with a margin of around six per cent, whereas the figure for VW is about half that, and it’s nearer minus two per cent for skint SEAT.

VW needs to maintain its long-held position: well below Audi, not premium, battling in the market frequented by its most natural rivals, such as Ford, Peugeot and Vauxhall

At SEAT, it’s time for the brand to re-invent itself and radically change its knackered logo before delivering the right, stripped out, less-is-more, fun cars for teens or 20-somethings on limited budgets. Look up that humble, honest, mid-eighties Ibiza and you’ll get an idea. Better still, the boxy, affordable, almost cheap ‘n’ nasty (but nice) Marbella from the same era (it had a lino-like floor and a ‘dashboard’ of even lower quality) would be perfect for kids today who want something cooler, smaller and cheaper than an entry-level Dacia.

Which leaves Skoda. It’s this marque, not VW itself, that’s rapidly moved upmarket to the point that it’s truly borderline premium. So the Volkswagen clan’s mass-market pecking order now goes Audi, Skoda, VW, Cupra and then SEAT.

Do you agree with Mike? Let is know in the comments section below...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Best electric car deals: today's top discounts and incentives on new EVs
Best electric car deals - header image

Best electric car deals: today's top discounts and incentives on new EVs

Making the switch to an EV? These car brands have an offer (or two) for you
Best cars & vans
28 Apr 2025
Volkswagen ID.Every1 concept: entry-level ID.1 EV will ‘still feel like a Volkswagen’
Volkswagen ID.Every1 concept - front action

Volkswagen ID.Every1 concept: entry-level ID.1 EV will ‘still feel like a Volkswagen’

The Volkswagen ID.1 will arrive in 2027 and look to start below £20,000
News
23 Apr 2025
Cutting-edge new AUDI E5 Sportback is the 776bhp, 480-mile EV estate… that we won’t see in the UK
AUDI E5 Sportback on display at Shanghai Motor Show - front

Cutting-edge new AUDI E5 Sportback is the 776bhp, 480-mile EV estate… that we won’t see in the UK

First offering from the joint venture between Audi and SAIC will, very confusingly, be sold by new AUDI sub-brand
News
23 Apr 2025
Volkswagen to extend its range with range-extender PHEVs for Europe
Volkswagen Touareg - front cornering

Volkswagen to extend its range with range-extender PHEVs for Europe

EV-lite range-extender technology could prolong the shelf-life of Volkswagen’s petrol engine offerings to 2030 and beyond
News
23 Apr 2025

Most Popular

New Kia PV5 Passenger MPV undercuts the VW ID.Buzz by a huge £25k
Kia PV5 Passenger - show front

New Kia PV5 Passenger MPV undercuts the VW ID.Buzz by a huge £25k

New entry into the electric people carrier market undercuts the VW ID. Buzz by a significant margin
News
29 Apr 2025
Car Deal of the Day: BMW’s ultimate luxury SUV at an unusually low price
BMW X7 - front

Car Deal of the Day: BMW’s ultimate luxury SUV at an unusually low price

German firm’s flagship SUV could never be called cheap but it is exceptional value at £735 a month – making it our Deal of the Day for Sunday 27 April
News
27 Apr 2025
New 2025 Kia PV5 van starts from a tempting £22,645
Kia PV5 Cargo on display at Commercial Vehicle Show - front 3/4

New 2025 Kia PV5 van starts from a tempting £22,645

All-new entry into the van market promises competitive pricing and comes with a range of up to 247 miles
News
30 Apr 2025