Volkswagen up! loses two NCAP stars as VW removes auto-braking function

Latest crash-test results see Euro NCAP dock stars in up!’s retest, as assessors criticise VW for removing AEB from its options list

The Volkwsagen up! city car has scored three stars in the latest round of Euro NCAP crash test results, down from the maximum five stars it was awarded when first assessed in 2011. While Euro NCAP tested the electric e-up!, the new score also applies to the facelifted petrol-powered up! due in the new year, as well as the mechanically identical SEAT Mii and Skoda Citigo.

Much of the blame for the two-star loss lies with the up!’s reduced safety assist score, and changing crash-test criteria. In 2011 the up! scored 86 per cent for safety assist technology, partly thanks to its seatbelt reminder and electronic stability control systems. In 2019 it was awarded just 55 per cent in the safety assist category.

Safest cars on sale in the UK

NCAP’s crash safety experts criticised Volkswagen’s decision to remove autonomous emergency braking (AEB) from the up!’s options list, although lane keep assist - a feature that was not previously available - is now fitted as standard.

Matthew Avery, director of research at Thatcham, said: “the withdrawal of its City AEB system is a major shortcoming, not least because consumers will be considering it as an affordable electric city-car option. The lack of an AEB system to avoid or mitigate collisions in a city-driving environment is therefore a significant omission.” 

Avery added that while the up! “still offers a respectable level of passive safety”, its overall score was “disappointing.”

What is Euro NCAP?

Commenting on the up!’s Euro NCAP downgrade, a spokesperson from Volkswagen said: “The up! was reassessed this year and achieved three stars, as we hoped it would. Excellent passenger protection and Lane Assist installed as standard – as well as curtain and side airbags – make it one of the safest vehicles in its class. Due to the fact that the test conditions have become significantly tougher in recent years, three stars can be considered a very good rating.”

Autonomous emergency braking works by scanning the road ahead for obstacles, first warning the driver before braking automatically they take no action to avoid a potential collision. 

This latest retest is not the first time modern safety assessments have been applied to older cars. In 2017, the Fiat Punto was awarded zero stars during its retest, and was removed from sale by its maker shortly afterwards. 

And earlier this month, the Volkwsagen Sharan was awarded four stars during its NCAP tests despite its rear door detaching during impact - an eventuality Volkwsagen said it had never seen demonstrated in real-world accident data.

Life for city cars looks tough under current and future regulations. As well as crash test criteria that are difficult for smaller cars to meet, unintended consequences linked to European Union carbon dioxide targets could see city cars die out altogether

This latest round of Euro NCAP tests did see some good news for Volkswagen, with the new Mk8 Golf awarded five stars. The Audi Q8, Ford Puma, MG HS, MG ZS EVNissan Juke and Ford Puma were also given five stars.

Click here to read our review of the new all-electric Volkswagen e-up!...


Volkswagen up! review
Volkswagen up! - front
Volkswagen up

Volkswagen up! review

The VW up! has been at the top of the city car class for a decade, and it’s still going strong
20 Jul 2021
City Car of the Year 2020: Volkswagen up!
Volkswagen up

City Car of the Year 2020: Volkswagen up!

The Volkswagen up! is the 2020 Auto Express City Car of the Year, with the Hyundai i10 and SEAT Mii Electric commended
13 Oct 2020

Most Popular

New Dacia Duster facelift priced from £13,995
Dacia Duster facelift - front
Dacia Duster

New Dacia Duster facelift priced from £13,995

The Dacia Duster has been updated for 2021 with subtle design tweaks and a new eight-inch infotainment screen
2 Aug 2021
New 2021 Volkswagen Taigo coupe-SUV breaks cover
Volkswagen Taigo R-Line - front
Volkswagen Taigo

New 2021 Volkswagen Taigo coupe-SUV breaks cover

The new VW Taigo is a sportier, more aggressive looking version of the brand’s T-Cross and is aimed at lifestyle buyers
29 Jul 2021
'Formula E could be on course for victory in its battle with F1'
Formula E opinion

'Formula E could be on course for victory in its battle with F1'

Mike Rutherford thinks there can only be one winner out of Formula One and Formula E
1 Aug 2021