“The Bentley Bentayga is brilliant but at this price, it should feel unique”

Editor-in-chief Steve Fowler explains what Aston Martin and Rolls-Royce’s forthcoming luxury SUVs can learn from Bentley’s Bentayga.

Opinion: Bentley bentayga

Bentley’s new Bentayga is a sensational machine. I’ve been lucky enough to spend a few days (and drive a few hundred miles) in one and have enjoyed it tremendously – it is without doubt the finest sporting SUV with some of the most exquisite detailing in design and finishing that I have ever seen. It’s simply stunning.

But is it the world’s greatest luxury SUV? Sadly not. For me, that honour goes to the Range Rover. How can that be?

Let’s just concentrate on the Bentley first. It is jaw-droppingly quick. Well if your mouth is even slightly open, the acceleration of the 600bhp W12 engine will force it open wider. This is an astonishingly fast car – faster than any SUV has a right (did I hear someone say need?) to be.

Bentley Bentayga vs Range Rover

It’s also beautifully refined – hushed beyond belief at times – while the ride when cruising is as it should be in a Bentley, soft and mellow.

Then there’s the quality of the interior – it’s simply peerless with leather stitched, chrome knurled and veneer polished in a way that only Bentley’s craftsmen know how. There’s plenty of tech on board, too, from active cruise control to Apple CarPlay – all essential in the modern Bentley. Oh and a great sound system.

In short, I love the Bentley Bentayga and will be deeply envious of those who buy one. But if I had £160,000 to spend on a luxury SUV, I’d buy a Range Rover – for one simple reason: it feels more bespoke. Not in a fixtures, fittings and trimmings way, but because there is nothing else that gives you the same overall experience.

• Bentley Bentayga Speed models on the way

The Bentley, brilliant thought it is, is based on a platform that already underpins the Audi Q7 and will form the basis of the next Porsche Cayenne. The Range Rover sits on its own: upright, majestic, spacious and with a design spirit that is the epitome of modern British cool. It makes the Bentley feel a little bit like a pastiche of British design; the Bentayga is the old red phone box, the Range Rover is the latest smartphone.

Bentley Bentayga - dash

Bentley’s designers and engineers have been constrained by certain hard points imposed upon them by a VW group platform. Which means the Bentayga feels very much like a Q7 from behind the wheel, if not in the finishing.

In the Range Rover you sit higher, you get a better view out and you look down on most other road users, literally and metaphorically. It gives you more of a feeling of space – and for many space equals luxury.

Sure the Bentayga runs rings around the Range Rover when it comes to driving dynamics. But what’s the point of a sporty SUV (and yes, I know SUV stands for Sports Utility Vehicle)? You simply can’t defy physics – the Bentayga is a tall, heavy vehicle as all SUVs are. It will never be as good to drive as a Continental, Flying Spur or Mulsanne. So why spend so much effort trying?

Best SUVs to buy now

Personally, I’d rather trade some of that ability (which will rarely get used) for a bit more comfort around town and on the school run. The Range Rover is a more comfortable car to live with day-to-day, if not as fast or as exhilarating to drive.

Clearly there are business reasons for Bentley to share a platform with its brethren, but I would dearly love to know what a Bentayga designed free from any of those restrictions would be like. That really would be some car.

And herein lies the message, warning if you like, to Aston Martin and Rolls-Royce and their forthcoming SUVs. At the price you’ll be charging, it has to feel like nothing else – for me that’s the true definition of luxury: a bespoke, exclusive experience. And that’s why the grand old Range Rover currently stands tall – there really is nothing else like it.

What do you think of the Bentley Bentayga? Joint the debate on Twitter, on Facebook or in the comments section below...

Recommended

New Bentley Bentayga Azure First Edition launched 
New Bentley Bentayga Azure First Edition - front
Bentley Bentayga SUV

New Bentley Bentayga Azure First Edition launched 

The Bentayga Azure First Edition is an even more luxurious version of Bentley’s popular SUV 
19 May 2022
New Bentley Bentayga Outdoor Pursuits collection launched
Bentley Bentayga Outdoor Pursuits collection - front
Bentley Bentayga SUV

New Bentley Bentayga Outdoor Pursuits collection launched

Bentley’s Mulliner coachbuilding division creates three lifestyle specifications for Bentayga SUV
20 Dec 2021
Bentley Bentayga review
Bentley Bentayga Hybrid - front
Bentley Bentayga

Bentley Bentayga review

The Bentley Bentayga is one of the most accomplished and glamorous SUVs around, but you pay for the privilege
24 Nov 2021

Most Popular

Range Rover vs Bentley Bentayga: 2022 twin test review
Range Rover vs Bentley Bentayga - both cars front tracking
Car group tests

Range Rover vs Bentley Bentayga: 2022 twin test review

All-new Range Rover takes on Bentley Bentayga in luxury SUV face-off
2 Jul 2022
How to find the cheapest petrol and diesel near you
Diesel pump
Tips & advice

How to find the cheapest petrol and diesel near you

Cheap fuel is hard to come by in the UK at the moment but there are ways that you can minimise what you pay for petrol and diesel
1 Jul 2022
All-electric MG 4 to launch in September
MG4 - front static
News

All-electric MG 4 to launch in September

MG says the new MG 4 will be the first in a series of models using MSP architecture
4 Jul 2022