Golf Plus v FR-V

VW’s new Golf Plus promises more space and flexibility than the standard hatch. Is it a better choice than Honda’s practical FR-V?

Golf Plus v FR-V

Sitting in between the standard Golf hatchback and the Touran compact MPV, the original Golf Plus was meant to be everyone’s favourite Volkswagen made more useful.

The trouble is, it ended up being more of a Golf minus the appeal. Undeterred, bosses are still thinking positive with the second-generation Golf Plus. But before you sell yourself on the idea of a more practical version of the MkVI, you should be aware the newcomer is based on the MkV platform.

Will the raft of design tweaks make up for this, and convince buyers they need a Golf with something extra? We find out by putting it up against the Honda FR-V, which strikes a similar balance between compact dimensions and people-carrying ability. It comes with the benefit of a sixth seat in-between driver and front passenger, and is priced in the same bracket as its rival.

We test the most financially attractive versions of both. Our VW gets the 120bhp 1.4-litre TSI petrol engine, and promises 44.8mpg economy and 146g/km emissions. It performs as well as the 138bhp 1.8-litre FR-V. So, does the new Golf Plus add up?

Verdict

We've got a lot of positive feedback for the Golf Plus... but that hasn’t made it a winner here. It just goes to show what a well engineered car the MkV Golf was – as there’s little wrong with the way the latest model drives. Even so, it’s hard not to feel short-changed, as buyers will miss out on the refinement and comfort that make the MkVI such a supreme all-rounder.

In the end, the Golf is held back by its lack of true purpose. Want practicality? Go for a proper compact-MPV. Fancy a conventional hatchback? Then buy a standard Golf and get VW’s latest chassis technology.

Honda’s FR-V is far more committed to versatility. It’s interesting enough to appeal to anyone wanting something less ordinary than the average MPV, while also offering six-seat flexibility. As a compact MPV with a twist, the Japanese car makes more sense than its rival.

1st: Honda FR-V It’s not the freshest of designs, but the FR-V still has bags of appeal. While it can’t match the VW’s more efficient engine, the innovative interior and decent driving experience help it to win against the revised Golf Plus.

2nd: VW Golf Plus WE can’t penalise the Golf Plus for not being a great compact MPV, because that’s not really what it’s trying to be. However, rivals are more practical and the latest Golf hatchback is a better option if you don’t need the extra space.

Have you considered?

Ford Fiesta review
Ford Fiesta - front
Ford Fiesta

Ford Fiesta review

The Fiesta is good fun and remains a solid buy, despite increasingly strong competition.
24 Sep 2020
Used Ford Fiesta review
Ford Fiesta Hatchback

Used Ford Fiesta review

A full used buyer’s guide on the Ford Fiesta covering the Fiesta Mk8 (2016-date)
25 Jun 2020
Volkswagen Golf review
Volkswagen Golf - front
Volkswagen Golf Hatchback

Volkswagen Golf review

The Volkswagen Golf continues to be an impressive all-rounder that justifies its price premium over family hatchback rivals
25 Mar 2020

Most Popular

New 2020 Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport turns up the wick to 296bhp
Volkswagen Golf GTI Hatchback

New 2020 Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport turns up the wick to 296bhp

The new Volkswagen Golf GTI Clubsport adds more power and gets an aero overhaul
13 Oct 2020
New Land Rover Discovery Sport PHEV 2020 review
Land Rover Discovery Sport

New Land Rover Discovery Sport PHEV 2020 review

The Land Rover Discovery Sport P300e plug-in hybrid promises 135mpg and an all-electric range of 38 miles, but does it deliver?
21 Oct 2020
Car exhaust smoke explained
British Steam Car
Tips & advice

Car exhaust smoke explained

Is your car suffering from a smoky exhaust? Our troubleshooting guide tells you the causes and what you need to do to fix it
22 Oct 2020