VW Golf GTD Vs Audi A3 TDI

The Golf GTI needs no introduction – but here’s a hot Volkswagen with a different combination of letters on its tailgate.

The new GTD has a punchy diesel engine under its bonnet, and aims to mix sharp handling and strong performance with excellent fuel economy. Hot diesel versions of VW’s legendary family car are nothing new, but the sixth-generation model is the fastest yet.

It takes its styling cues from the GTI, has a powerful 2.0-litre TDI engine and is available with three or five doors. But will its heavier diesel unit compromise the class-leading dynamic abilities that make the GTI so impressive?

The engineers at VW sister firm Audi certainly don’t think so. They’ve slipped the same 168bhp unit into the A3 Sportback. In new Sport trim, it doesn’t look like an out-and-out hot-hatch, but is sure to appeal to buyers who prefer a more subtle approach.

Our contenders are separated by only a few hundred pounds on price and an even smaller margin in performance. So, which will come out on top?

Verdict

As our two contenders are so similar, you would expect this to be a close-run finish. But the VW and Audi have completely different characters. Although they share the same engine, have practical five-door bodies and feature high-quality cabins, they don’t go about their jobs in the same way.

Don’t be fooled by the subtle design of the A3 Sportback – behind its conservative exterior is a serious high-performance hatch. It’s fast, composed and refined, but doesn’t shout about its performance. The Audi also feels like a premium product... yet the VW is more sporty to look at, sit in and drive.

That’s why it wins. From behind the wheel, the Golf is more fun than the A3, but it’s also more frugal and refined. The smoother engine, more capable chassis and special cabin confirm the GTD as an incredibly desirable family car.