Long-term tests

Honda e: long-term test review

Final report: can you live with the Honda e without home charging? Yes

Overall Auto Express Rating

4.0 out of 5

Verdict

There are few more interesting and exciting cars on sale than the Honda e. It looks great, is excellent fun to drive and is the perfect city runabout. If you can live with the limited range, you won’t be disappointed – we just hope we see more of this from Honda.

  • Mileage: 3,226
  • Efficiency: 3.0 miles per kWh

After eight months, my time with the little Honda e is up, so now I shall attempt to answer the question I posed last year: is it possible for someone with neither off-street parking  nor the ability to charge at home to run an electric car? In a word, yes, but it does require some compromise.

As for the Honda e itself, it’s a cracking little city car, and is the perfect retort to anyone who says electric cars are boring. First of all, look at it! I’ve never driven any car in my eight years at Auto Express that has generated so much interest from other road users and passers-by.

I’ll admit the Charge Yellow paintwork is a little bright, but this isn’t exactly a car that flies under the radar, so a bold colour suits its character pretty well. The proportions are perfect, the design is wonderful, while the cabin feels really special – and totally unlike anything we’ve ever seen from Honda.

Living with the little EV – and being able to charge it when I needed to – was less of a problem than I had anticipated. Living on the third floor of an apartment block meant I was fully reliant on public chargers, yet rarely was I ever forced into using anything other than the trio of Source London charge points at the end of my street.

On average, I’d charge the e once or twice a week at around £10 a pop, which would give me anywhere in the region of 90-120 miles, depending on the weather. I never had to wait for a charging bay, there was never a fault with any of the charge points, and the whole experience really was rather painless.

It might sound totally obvious, but it’s important to remember that if your lifestyle doesn’t suit a range of only 90-120 miles, then this really isn’t the EV for you. It’s fortunate that I often have access to a second car, thanks to all of the reviews and tests we create at Auto Express, so any longer trips I had to make could be done in that.

When I was forced into taking the Honda on trips in excess of 100 miles, they did require some patience and planning, relying on service-station charge points. But they’re not impossible – they just take a little longer.

However as a city car – which is what the e is – it really is easy to love and hard to fault. What still impresses me is the ride quality; there are executive saloons that don’t ride as well as the little Honda thanks to its highly sophisticated fully independent suspension system; it’s something you usually see on much larger and more expensive cars.

The result is a car that can tackle rutted city streets and ride over potholes without you even noticing them. It really is superb.

Then there’s the comically small turning circle; anytime I’d made a wrong turn or missed a junction (all too easily done if I was following the Honda’s awful navigation system), spinning the car around in the middle of the road never got boring.

Things I don’t like so much, apart from the infotainment, include storage. Having no dedicated space for the charging cables means they take up lots of room in the already-small boot. And thanks to the limited range, you have to take them everywhere!

Honda e: second report

Cold weather proved to be a testing time for our electric Honda e supermini

  • Mileage: 2,860
  • Economy: 3.2 miles per kWh

Life with the little Honda e, given the rather trying circumstances we’re all living through at the moment, is a genuinely uplifting experience. It’s a car that puzzles, delights and shocks people every day; some laugh, some point and some try to grab a picture with their smartphone. Wherever it goes, its presence provokes a reaction I’ve not had with any other car in the eight years that I’ve worked at Auto Express.

But behind the cutesy looks and pop-out door handles is a car that does require some sacrifice to live with – although day to day, in and around West London where I live, the Honda is a breeze to run. There’s a public charger 30 seconds from my flat, where it can be charged overnight for about £10, and its dinky dimensions and hilariously small turning circle make parking and battling London traffic fun. Almost...

Outside of London, however, things do get a little tricky. Last summer, not long after I collected the car, I had to make a 550-mile trip from Milton Keynes, Bucks, up to Newcastle and then back down to London. Knowing that the Honda was going to spend the majority of its time within the confines of the M25 the rest of the time, I thought it would be an interesting – and anxiety-inducing – test to see how the Honda fared.

With a bit of planning and plenty of patience, the journey was not as painful as I had imagined. The first 240-mile leg, for example, involved five and a half hours of driving and just over an hour and a half of charging to get to the North East. It was cheap, too, costing me only £15.18 in electricity, and getting around 120 miles out of a charge was much better than I had expected on the motorway. On average, I was seeing around four miles per kWh.

One thing I did have to adapt was my driving style. It seems there is a sweet spot, at around 60mph, where you can maximise the Honda’s range. Any quicker and there’s a noticeable drop off in terms of economy, so sharing the inside lane with HGVs and other thrifty EV owners is something I had to get used to. But the Honda is a great cruiser with superb refinement and a brilliant ride quality for such a small car.

In fact, the Honda almost did much of the driving for me, because the trip gave me the opportunity to use the car’s decent adaptive cruise control and lane-keep assist systems. Again, finding this sort of kit on a car this small is quite rare. But then again, the Honda is far from cheap.

Fast forward several months to the winter, and life with the Honda becomes a very different ball game. During the warmer months, getting 120 miles on a full charge was little effort, but once the temperature drops to single figures, the range falls to around 80 miles – that’s quite some difference and requires another level of planning if you intend to make longer journeys.

No matter how carefully you drive, or how good you are at leaning on the regenerative braking and reading the traffic ahead, winter is not the electric car’s friend. I even inflated the tyres to 40psi to see if that would make any difference, but it didn’t. However, this isn’t a problem specific to the Honda, because most other electric cars suffer from the same ‘phantom’ range during the winter months.

I’ve also found that the estimated range from the Honda’s trip computer is quite the pessimist. On a cold day with a full battery, the readout has often said that only 60 miles will be possible, when in reality I’ve driven closer to 80. Having said that, if the readout was being optimistic it would be a far greater issue.

With warmer weather on the way I’m hoping that the Honda will begin to travel a bit further with every recharge, because the more I drive it, the more I like it. I just wonder if my patience with the range would have worn thin by now if the rest of the car weren’t so impressive.

Honda e: first report

A lack of home charging hasn't spoilt our time with our new Honda e

  • Mileage: 2,260
  • Economy: 3.6 miles per kWh

One of the latest arrivals on the Auto Express fleet, the funky new Honda e, has been helping me to answer one very simple question: can you live with an electric car without being able to charge at home?

As with many people who these sorts of urban EVs are aimed at, I live in a flat without any option of charging at home. With a huge proportion of drivers living in urban areas and electric car sales growing, this is going to be a theme that becomes increasingly common. How exactly are people expected to live with them? A reliance on the public charging network is the only realistic option, so you can consider me a guinea pig.

This obvious compromise that I’d have to make when running an EV is the one thing that has stopped me from making the switch sooner. So it was going to take something pretty special to come along and change my mind. But the Honda e is just that; not only is it a cool and original approach to an electric car, crucially, it’s also very desirable. Few other EVs manage to achieve that. 

Of course, the design won’t be to all tastes. Some people laugh, others stare and some genuinely have no idea what it is and want to chat about it. Very few cars attract attention in the same way as the Honda e –and no doubt the Charge Yellow finish of our car has something to do with it.

The version we have on our fleet is a top-spec Honda e Advance. Inclusive of the Government’s £3,000 grant for zero-emission plug-in cars, the Honda e will set you back £29,660. On a 36-month PCP deal, that works out at £311 per month if you can stump up a £6,500 deposit. Whichever way you look at it, this is a small electric car with a big price tag.

What do you get for that? Well, quite a bit, actually. As standard this Advance model comes with a 35.5kWh battery that feeds a more powerful 152bhp rear- mounted electric motor for a claimed range of 137 miles. Inside, there’s the full-width infotainment set-up with digital wing mirrors and rear-view mirror, heated seats and steering wheel, wireless Apple CarPlay, a sunroof, parking sensors and a rear camera. Oh, and the cool pop-out door handles. 

There isn’t a single option fitted to our car, either. Charge Yellow is the only paint colour that’s standard; black, blue, white and grey are all £550, which seems a little odd. You can add leather, but the standard seats are finished in a soft-yet-textured fabric that looks great and is comfortable. 

So the obvious question is how much of a headache is charging it? In short, it’s not been an issue. Over the past month or so, I’d usually charge it up once a week at the Source London point at the end of my street. With around 15 per cent left in the battery, a full top-up takes roughly four hours from a 7kW unit, which costs around £9. I’ve been averaging upwards of 100 miles on a full charge, which is 30 miles short of the official range, but I’ve had 120 miles out of it on a longer motorway drive. However, living and driving around central London – the Honda’s natural environment – 100 miles seems to be the average return so far.

And for battling traffic, squeezing through width restrictors and nipping into gaps, the Honda is proving to be the perfect runaround. Of course, outside of its comfort zone it could well be a different story. And a 270-mile trip north up the M1 awaits.

Model:Honda e Advance
On fleet since:August 2020
Price new:£29,660
Drivetrain:35.5kWh battery, single electric motor, 152bhp
CO2/tax:0g/km/£0
Options:None
Insurance*:Group: 29 Quote: £534
Mileage/econ:3,226/3.0m/kWh
Any problems?None

*Insurance quote from AA (0800 107 0680) for a 42-year-old in Banbury, Oxon, with three points.

Most Popular

'The death of cheap cars will be a travesty for personal mobility'
Opinion cheap cars
Opinion

'The death of cheap cars will be a travesty for personal mobility'

Our appetite for small, cheap cars is as strong as ever - although Mike Rutherford warns they may no longer be profitable
12 Sep 2021
New Toyota RAV4 Adventure heads up 2022 model refresh
Toyota RAV4 Adventure
News

New Toyota RAV4 Adventure heads up 2022 model refresh

The rugged Toyota RAV4 Adventure targets lifestyle buyers with a tough-looking new front bumper and interior tweaks
14 Sep 2021
E10 petrol explained: UK prices, checker tool and is it OK for your car?
Petrol pump
News

E10 petrol explained: UK prices, checker tool and is it OK for your car?

E10 petrol is up to 10 per cent ethanol and is available at UK fuel stations now as part of the bid to cut CO2 emissions
1 Sep 2021