Long-term tests

Jaguar XF

Third report: Key encounter as our cat meets XFR brother.

  • The starting procedure in the Jaguar is pure theatre, but I never tire of it – and passengers invariably love it. The way the air vents slowly rotate and the blinking red starter button pulses into life provides the sort of feelgood factor few cars can match.
  • Former Auto Express road test editor Chris Thorp complained about our model’s ride comfort, and I have to agree with him. The optional 20-inch alloys look great, but their low-profile tyres compromise the XF’s low-speed ride.

Two keys: two very different experiences! Our long-term Jaguar XF diesel met up with its hot XFR stablemate during a recent photoshoot (Issue 1,061) at Rockingham Motor Speedway, Northants – and it highlighted just how understated the flagship looks.

Our oil-burner was finished in the same moody black paint as the 503bhp supercharged saloon we had on test, so we played a quick game of spot the difference.

Apart from the odd 296bhp, all our car was missing were the range-topper’s smart alloy wheels, its pair of bonnet vents and the chrome-rimmed air intakes in the front bumper.

The XFR is a stunning achievement – fast, stylish and comfortable in equal measure. But our long-termer didn’t feel like a poor relation. Its luxurious cabin and relaxed performance are a constant reminder why it’s our reigning Car of the Year. When deciding who drove which model on the trip home from our test, there wasn’t a short straw to draw!

Our XF is pretty practical, too – which isn’t something you expect from an executive saloon. In fact, since inheriting the key from former road test editor Chris Thorp, I’ve been inundated with requests to borrow the Jag. The least likely came from editor in chief David Johns, who needed to move a giant glass table top. His long-term Mercedes C-Class doesn’t have folding rear seats, unlike our XF – which was perfect for the job.

It’s also great for carrying a full load of passengers, thanks to its spacious rear seats. The only thing is, I find myself apologising for the firm ride when driving around town. The optional alloy wheels do our big cat few favours – although they look great. Elsewhere, I’m a big fan of the uprated Bowers & Wilkins sound system. With its full iPod integration, it has transformed my daily drive to and from the office, and I rarely bother listening to the radio. But that’s probably just as well, because colleagues have complained about its poor reception.

In terms of repairs, the Jag hasn’t cost us a penny yet, but its fuel economy has taken a knock as my commute is so heavily congested. Still, 29.5mpg represents a decent return for such a luxurious saloon. It’s also one area where the XFR can’t hope to compete – it achieved only 17.3mpg during our group test.

Second Opinion

Previous reports on the XF have highlighted a problem with the sticking fuel filler flap. But I think I may have found the solution. You have to press the flap to unlatch it, yet it seems to need a firm push. This happened to me once, and I managed to reset the flap for a second attempt simply by activating and then releasing the central locking system. It’s a minor niggle, though, and the sheer sense of occasion from the driving experience sets the XF apart.

Dean Gibson Senior sub-editor

Most Popular

Energy firms want the right to switch off electric cars charging at home
Electric cars

Energy firms want the right to switch off electric cars charging at home

New powers being sought to allow energy providers to turn off high-drain devices to manage electricity network
18 Sep 2020
Audi A3 vs Mercedes A-Class
Car group tests

Audi A3 vs Mercedes A-Class

The Audi A3 and Mercedes A-Class are strong competitors in the premium hatchback market - we find out which is best
19 Sep 2020
New Rolls-Royce Ghost 2020 review
Rolls-Royce Ghost

New Rolls-Royce Ghost 2020 review

The all-new luxury Rolls-Royce Ghost saloon brings new levels of refinement
18 Sep 2020