'Too many VW Group models end up pointlessly competing with each other'

Volkswagen Group has five separate brands constantly competing with each other, but only the consumer loses out, says Mike Rutherford

OPINION New Volkswagen logo

The largest employers on the planet – the likes of the Chinese Army, McDonalds, our NHS, and the Volkswagen Group – don’t get everything right.

For instance, despite having more workers, brands, versatility and street cred than its closest rival (Toyota), the German giant sells fewer cars, suffers bigger fines (mostly Dieselgate-related) and makes lower profits. Yes, I’m impressed that the group employs up to 700,000 people across the globe, but more of these staffers must start the long-overdue process of separating out the four (five if we include Cupra) mainstream sister brands within this ever-growing family.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Best SUVs to buy now

The way I see it, Skoda and SEAT sit at the bottom, Cupra and Volkswagen hold the middle ground, and Audi resides nearer the top. That said, they are all far too close in terms of bottom-mid-range model line-ups, product quality (each is about the same), prices and more. Often these brands and their products pointlessly compete with each other in their own showrooms. That’s daft, and horrendously expensive. And it is you, dear consumer, who pays for this in-house competition, which merely converts, say, a SEAT customer into a VW buyer. Ridiculous.

A perfect example of illogical overlapping is that while the marketing team at Skoda spends fortunes promoting its 3.6m sub-supermini (Citigo), there are near-identical versions of the car being expensively marketed by a different army at Volkswagen (Up!), then a third bunch at SEAT (Mii). What’s the point? It’d be more sensible for the VW Group to have just one entry-level/sub-supermini range. The most natural bargain/value brand is Skoda, so give the Czech firm the sole rights to produce, badge and sell this little runabout. And if it’s a must for the three brands to continue with their own versions, let’s at least have very distinct first-time-buyer, utility/commercial, and perhaps even luxury versions.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

Michael Jost, product strategy boss at the VW Group is coming around to this, and has confessed that he needs to “manage brand identities more clearly”. About time too, mate.

Having driven them all, I can tell you that there is very little (apart from badge snobbery) between the bog-standard 1.0-litre versions of the Audi A1, SEAT Ibiza, Skoda Fabia and VW Polo. None of them feels like a bargain-basement or a premium product. All are better-than-average, boringly similar, and their prices aren’t that different.

A £12k, stripped-out, bargain-basement Fabia at the bottom, followed by a slightly higher-spec Ibiza, an even higher-spec Polo, then a £20k truly premium A1 (the current one isn’t) would be a far more sensible and diverse supermini mix for the VW Group.

It could, and should, be so cost-effective and simple. All SEATs and Skodas would be two-wheel drive, modestly equipped and such great value that Dacia would wince. Then Cupras and VWs could be slightly more luxurious and classy. Audis that are premium and, in turn, pricey will then sit proudly at the top of the pile. Think of this as the end of ill-thought-out overlapping, and the start of proper choice for VW Group customers.

Do you agree with Mike? Let us know what you think in the comments below...



VW Emissions scandal update 2

VW emissions scandal: VW installed ‘defeat devices’ in thousands of cars, High Court finds

The UK’s High Court has ruled that VW installed devices to cheat emissions tests in thousands of its cars
6 Apr 2020

Mountune52 releases Volkswagen Golf GTI boost

VAG division of Mountune announces Stage 2+ performance boost for Mk7 and Mk7.5 Volkswagen Golf GTI
31 Mar 2020

New Volkswagen e-BULLI electric camper van revealed

Volkswagen has introduced an all-electric concept version of the classic T1 Samba Bus, with 82bhp and a 120 mile-plus range
20 Mar 2020

New Volkswagen ID.3 set to arrive in summer despite software delay fears

The arrival of the new Volkswagen ID.3 is still scheduled for summer despite rumours that a software delay could set back deliveries for UK customers.
4 Mar 2020

Most Popular

Mazda MX-5

New Mazda MX-5 2020 review

The popular Mazda MX-5 has been updated for 2020, but with the changes comes a jump in price
5 Apr 2020

New Dacia Spring Electric confirmed to arrive next year

Bosses confirm the new Dacia Spring Electric will arrive in showrooms next year and set to become Europe's cheapest electric car.
7 Apr 2020
Car group tests

Kia Soul EV vs MG ZS EV

The second-generation Kia Soul EV faces the value-for-money MG ZS EV in an SUV shootout
4 Apr 2020