'Does JLR really need the new Defender in its line-up?'

With so many other SUVs in their model line-up, Steve Fowler asks whether JLR really needed to build the new Defender

OPINION Land Rover Defender

It's been a long time coming and is one of the most eagerly anticipated cars in ages, but the covers have finally come off the all-new Land Rover Defender. 

Once again, the Land Rover team has produced a stunning car with huge desirability. I love its rugged, modern looks and some of the clever engineering that has gone into it. Do I want one? You bet.

• It’s back: new 2020 Land Rover Defender reinvents the icon

At this point, you’re probably waiting for a big ‘but’ to ride into town, and here it is: I’m not sure the world really needs a new Defender. More to the point, I’m not sure that Jaguar Land Rover does. 

Let me explain. The market for really utilitarian SUVs like the old model is tiny. There are plenty of romantics (not least in JLR) who wanted to see the Defender reborn, but are they going to spend more than £45,000 on one? And if you are one of the few who really need serious off-road ability, does Land Rover (or others) not already offer something that fits the bill? 

The market for mainstream SUVs is huge, though, so that’s where Defender is being pitched. And here’s the rub: many of its main rivals are already in Land Rover and Jaguar showrooms. Between the Defender price points of £45,000 and £79,000, Jaguar Land Rover already has eight (yes eight) other SUVs. Count ’em: Discovery, Discovery Sport, Evoque, Velar, Range Rover Sport plus Jaguar’s E-, F- and I-Pace. The Defender makes it nine. You’ll be spoiled for choice.

Yes, I’d love a Defender (it replaces a Discovery on my wish list – as it will for many others), but I’m disappointed that, among all its tech, there’s no strong electrification story (which we’re often told is ideal for off-road work). And wouldn’t we all have loved a cut-price Defender that doesn’t overlap with the rest of the JLR range even more?

All that said, it will, of course, sell by the bucketload. But at what price for the other SUVs in JLR’s line-up? 

Do you agree with Steve that JLR does not need the new Defender? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below...

Recommended

Bowler reveals classic Defender 110 will live on with V8 power
Land Rover Defender

Bowler reveals classic Defender 110 will live on with V8 power

Derbyshire based Bowler developing road-going four-seat V8 powered Defender Station Wagon for first vehicle under JLR ownership
4 Nov 2020
New Land Rover Defender 90 P400 2020 review
Land Rover Defender

New Land Rover Defender 90 P400 2020 review

The smaller Land Rover Defender 90 P400 joins the range with mild-hybrid power
28 Oct 2020
New Land Rover Defender 90 P300 2020 review
Land Rover Defender

New Land Rover Defender 90 P300 2020 review

The new Land Rover Defender 90 P300 shows its strengths off road
28 Oct 2020
Mid-size Premium SUV of the Year 2020: Land Rover Defender
Land Rover Defender

Mid-size Premium SUV of the Year 2020: Land Rover Defender

The Land Rover Defender is the 2020 Auto Express Premium Mid-size SUV of the Year, with the BMW X3 and Porsche Macan commended
13 Oct 2020

Most Popular

BMW 5 Series vs Audi A6 vs Volvo S90
BMW 5 Series vs Audi A6 vs Volvo S90 - main
Car group tests

BMW 5 Series vs Audi A6 vs Volvo S90

Can plug-in hybrid power create a clear winner out of the BMW 5 Series, Audi A6 or Volvo S90
23 Jan 2021
Best small 4x4s to buy 2021
Dacia Duster ford
Best cars & vans

Best small 4x4s to buy 2021

Need 4x4 capability without big SUV fuel bills? Take a look our top 10 small 4x4s instead
6 Jan 2021
New Lotus ‘Type 131’ due in 2021 as Elise, Exige and Evora bow out
Lotus range
Lotus

New Lotus ‘Type 131’ due in 2021 as Elise, Exige and Evora bow out

A new look Lotus line-up is teased with heavy influence from Evija hypercar expected
24 Jan 2021