Skip advert
Advertisement

New Smart ForFour Brabus Xclusive 2017 review

Smart's ForFour city car gets the hot Brabus treatment, so we take it for a spin

Overall Auto Express rating

3.0

How we review cars
Find your Smart ForFour
Compare deals from trusted partners on this car and previous models.
Or are you looking to sell your car?
Value my car
Fast, no-nonsense car selling
Value my car

The Brabus ForFour may be characterful, but there’s no getting around its obvious flaws. The styling upgrades give it real personality, and it’s entertainingly agile around town, yet it leaves a lot to be desired against more capable hot hatch rivals. The powertrain is pretty underwhelming, while the handling doesn’t entertain or inspire like a souped-up small car should. When all is said and done, this is a not-so-hot city runabout for the price of a well-specified Ford Fiesta ST.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Brabus is a German brand with a long and illustrious history tuning a huge variety of Mercedes models. Many of them have been extremely fast, loud and expensive, but 16 years ago Brabus surprised us by setting up a joint venture with city car maker Smart.

The Smart Brabus ForTwo is now in its third iteration, while the ForFour you see here is the second four-seat model to emerge from the partnership. It shares much with the new Renault Twingo GT, including the familiar 0.9-litre turbo engine tweaked to deliver 107bhp thanks to boosted fuel pressure, a revised air intake and sports exhaust system. There’s also a useful 35Nm of extra torque.

Unfortunately (and unlike the Twingo GT) Smart has chosen not to offer a manual gearbox with the Brabus, meaning you’re stuck with a six-speed dual-clutch automatic. Memories of the sluggish and horribly jerky shifts of old auto-only Smarts come flooding back, but thankfully this unit is considerably smoother and quicker than before.

There’s decent response from the wheel-mounted paddles, while a 40 per cent faster shift and Race Start launch control function give it a sportier edge. It all means the Smart is a breeze to thread around town, though there’s nothing like the sense of interaction you’ll have with a manual gearbox.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Used - available now

Qashqai

2018 Nissan

Qashqai

45,686 milesManualDiesel1.5L

Cash £10,899
View Qashqai
Sandero

2022 Dacia

Sandero

10,921 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £9,499
View Sandero
C-Class Estate

2024 Mercedes

C-Class Estate

58,439 milesAutomaticPetrol1.5L

Cash £24,999
View C-Class Estate
Fiesta

2023 Ford

Fiesta

25,169 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £12,799
View Fiesta

Best hot hatchbacks

This isn’t helped by the engine itself, either. It’s nippy around town, feeling notably more perky than the standard ForFour, but it never feels fast out on the open road. It’s 100kg heavier than the ForTwo, and also feels unwilling to rev, meaning you find yourself changing up early to make the most of the torque. 

It retains the characteristic thrum on start-up, but once on the move the sound is disappointingly muted. Unlike in the ForTwo, the new exhaust has very little effect in the four-seat Smart, and at motorway speeds the rev counter is the only indication of how hard the engine is actually working. Our test fuel economy of 37mpg shows it's not especially economical, either.

It’s a shame, because the Brabus additions extend to more than a power boost.  Firmer suspension, recalibrated variable ratio steering and a slackened ESP system aim to provide more fun at the wheel. It feels tauter and more composed than a standard Smart in fast corners, but loses none of the almost comic agility and that tight turning circle that standard car is famous for. The weightier steering still lacks any sort of feel, however, and with understeer the default handling trait there’s still no sense of the ForFour being rear-wheel drive.

Best city cars

The ride isn’t as stiff as you’d expect, though, especially when you take a look at those 17-inch wheels. Nevertheless, this is still a car that crashes into big potholes and bounces over high speed bumps – a MINI runs rings around it in this regard. There’s incessant tyre roar, too, and wind noise is a problem at speed.

We’ve no complaints about the funky styling, however. Brabus has brought just the right amount of sportiness with the big wheels, twin pipes and chunky bumpers – without going over the top. Quality is good inside, too, plus our Xclusive model comes with plenty of kit.

That’s the least we expect given the price; The Brabus ForFour starts from an already questionable £16,815, but this car is nearly £20k before options. That sort of money would give you the pick of a number of more practical, nicer to drive and far faster hot hatches.

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Nissan Qashqai

Nissan Qashqai

RRP £27,415Avg. savings £5,924 off RRP*Used from £12,300
Volkswagen Golf

Volkswagen Golf

RRP £24,625Avg. savings £2,462 off RRP*Used from £12,091
Renault Clio

Renault Clio

RRP £16,160Avg. savings £3,343 off RRP*Used from £9,595
Volkswagen Polo

Volkswagen Polo

RRP £14,480Avg. savings £1,864 off RRP*Used from £7,850
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New 2027 Vauxhall Corsa aiming to set the supermini standard
New 2027 Vauxhall Corsa exclusive image

New 2027 Vauxhall Corsa aiming to set the supermini standard

We’ve got all the gossip on Vauxhall’s all-new Corsa coming in 2027, and it might finally shake off its conservative image
News
22 Aug 2025
The future of Skoda: CEO talks new cars and how it beat BMW
The future of Skoda

The future of Skoda: CEO talks new cars and how it beat BMW

We’re not at peak Skoda yet – a flagship electric SUV and a small hatch will soon boost the line-up explains CEO Klaus Zellmer, in a long chat with Au…
News
23 Aug 2025
We're past the peak! New cars are growing far too complex, frustrating and expensive
Frustrating modern cars - Opinion, Dean Gibson

We're past the peak! New cars are growing far too complex, frustrating and expensive

Senior test editor Dean Gibson thinks that modern cars are becoming too complex and frustrating, signalling the end of ‘peak car’
Opinion
20 Aug 2025