Car group tests

Audi A5 Cabriolet vs Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet

It’s open season as Audi’s upmarket new four-seater A5 Cabriolet soft-top meets the classy Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet

With summer just around the corner, the lure of a classy convertible is stronger than ever. Happily, there has been a glut of new soft-top models recently, and the latest is the Audi A5 Cabriolet.

Based on the handsome Coupe, it promises a desirable mix of wind-in-the-hair thrills, four-seater practicality and unrivalled premium appeal. And with a lower kerbweight and stiffer chassis, the A5 should be as refined and composed on the move as its fixed-head cousin.

However, before Audi can celebrate, the A5 must see off the challenge of the classy Mercedes C-Class Convertible. So which of our contenders breezes off with the win?

Head-to-head

Model: Audi A5 Cabriolet 2.0 TDI S line S tronicMercedes C 220 d Cabriolet 4MATIC AMG Line auto
Price: £42,625£43,905
Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl diesel2.1-litre 4cyl diesel
Power/torque: 187bhp/400Nm168bhp/400Nm
Transmission:Seven-speed twin-clutch automatic, front-wheel drive Nine-speed automatic, four-wheel drive 
0-60mph:8.0 seconds7.9 seconds
Top speed:144mph140mph
Test economy: 42.8mpg37.3mpg
CO2/tax: 122g/km/£140134g/km/£140
Equipment:Sat-nav, parking sensors, 18-inch alloy wheels, LED headlamps, part-leather trim, DAB radio, Bluetooth, autonomous emergency braking, sports suspension, ambient interior lightingSat-nav, powered wind deflectors, heated seats, LED headlamps, parking assistance, DAB, Bluetooth, climate control, autonomous emergency braking, 18-inch alloys, ambient interior lighting

Audi A5 Cabriolet

  • • For: Smart looks, smooth diesel engine, spacious interior.
  • • Against: Wind turbulence on motorway, S tronic box’s ratios, expensive options.

The A5 Cabriolet made its debut in 2007, but after a decade in service it has finally been replaced by an all-new second-generation model. Based on the same scalable MLB platform as the A5 Coupe and A4 saloon, the newcomer is lighter, more efficient and faster than the old car.

The 187bhp 2.0-litre TDI is used throughout the range, and in combination with the seven-speed S tronic auto box and launch control, it allowed the Audi to cover 0-60mph in 8.0 seconds, which was just a tenth down on the four-wheel-drive Mercedes.

Best convertible cars on sale

The A5 turned the tables during our third, fourth and fifth-gear tests, where it was quicker than its rival. However, extremely tall sixth and seventh ratios meant the car was sluggish from 50-70mph; our test track’s straight wasn’t long enough for the new Audi Cabriolet to record a time in top gear.

In the real world this means the car is turning 1,500rpm at 70mph and it struggles to settle on a gear when cruising, because the gearbox often kicks down at the slightest touch of the throttle.

Still, at least the gearchanges are swift and slick, while the TDI has the edge here for smoothness.Turn in to a corner and it’s clear the Cabriolet can’t match its Coupe cousin for rigidity. Even so, the stiffer MLB platform means it remains impressively composed over rough surfaces. There’s some shimmy through the chassis, particularly in bumpy bends, but it’s far from  intrusive. Grip is also plentiful, and our car’s  £600 optional adaptive dampers delivered decent body control in their sportiest setting.

In Comfort mode the Audi had the edge for ride comfort as well. Large potholes and ridges sent a shudder through the cabin, but most of the time the new A5 did a good job of soaking up bumps in the surface.

Refinement is also impressive, and with the triple-layer Acoustic hood in place the car was as quiet on the move as the Mercedes.

Lowering the roof requires nothing more than a touch of a button, but it took nearly a second and half longer to stow than the Mercedes’, at 19.9 seconds. Occupants aren’t as well protected from buffeting as they are in the C-Class, either.

The Audi is available with a £600 wind break, but the manually set up unit is fiddly to install and doesn’t allow you to use the rear seats once in place. And while heated front chairs are standard, there’s no option to add a Mercedes-style Airscarf system.

On the plus side, the Audi’s rear bench offers more head and legroom for passengers, while its 380-litre boot is bigger and better shaped.

Testers’ notes:

  • • Controls: Intuitive MMI dial in centre console provides access to wide range of cabin functions and car settings through screen.
  • • Upholstery: S line specification brings leather bolsters as well as heated seats as standard. 
  • • Finish: Silver insert on the dashboard helps to lift the A5’s interior, which has a top-quality feel. 

Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet

  • • For: Impressive comfort and refinement, integrated wind deflectors.
  • • Against: Expensive to buy, coarse diesel engine, cramped in the rear. 

The sleek and stylish Mercedes C-Class is our current favourite upmarket compact convertible. Not only does it look the part, it’s also decent to drive, generously equipped and features a particularly well-integrated fabric roof.

On paper, the C 220 d is at an immediate disadvantage to its rival, with its 168bhp 2.1-litre diesel 19bhp down on power compared with the Audi’s 2.0-litre unit. However, its 400Nm torque figure is a match for the A5’s, and in combination with the closely stacked ratios of its nine-speed gearbox and its four-wheel-drive traction, it allowed the C 220 d to sprint from 0-60mph in 7.9 seconds, which was a tenth faster than the Audi.

The result was equally close during our in-gear tests, where the Mercedes trailed the A5 in the lower ratios, but was slightly quicker in sixth.

In the real world there’s little to separate our duo. While the C-Class’s 2.1-litre diesel can’t match the A5’s 2.0 for smoothness and refinement, the responsive nine-speed auto keeps the engine in the muscular mid-range, so you can make brisk progress without having to extend the four-cylinder.

In corners it’s immediately clear the heavier Mercedes isn’t as agile as its rival. The steering is direct and well weighted and there’s plenty of grip, but body movements aren’t as well controlled and it responds to direction changes more lazily.

However, Mercedes has done a good job in strengthening the car’s bodyshell during its transition from coupe to convertible. Severe bumps result in some flex, but the movement is small and doesn’t upset the car’s composure.

This chassis stiffness has further benefits for the ride, which is reasonably smooth at low speed and supple on the motorway. It’s not perfect, though, with sharp ridges sending a sickening crash through the structure.

In other respects, refinement is good. As with the Audi, there’s more wind and noise with the roof up than in the coupe, but it’s far from intrusive.

The electric hood is lowered in 18.5 seconds and neatly stowed under a panel behind the rear seats. Yet it’s when on the move that the Mercedes really proves its drop-top credentials.

For starters, it benefits from standard powered wind deflectors – one between the rear headrests and another that rises out of the windscreen header rail. These do an excellent job of cutting turbulence, allowing you to travel four-up in comfort.

Other welcome features include the Airscarf system, which blows warm air on the neck of the driver and passenger, plus heated seats.

Testers’ notes: 

  • • Display: AMG Line models get seven-inch screen as standard, with no online features, but our car has larger connected display as part of £1,300 upgrade. 
  • • COMAND: Familiar click wheel operates Mercedes’ COMAND control system. It’s simple to use. 
  • • Steering wheel: AMG Line has a flat-bottomed wheel, but isn’t that sporty on the road. The A5 is more agile.

Verdict

First place: Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet

When cruising four-up with the top down, the C-Class excels. It’s not as sharp to drive as its rival here, but it’s a better convertible and packed with handy features to make life more comfortable. Go for the well-equipped Sport in two-wheel-drive guise, and the price gap to the Audi narrows.

Second place: Audi A5 Cabriolet

The A5 Cabriolet is a handsome, composed and refined four-seater convertible. It also offers decent practicality, is more attractively priced and will cost business users less. Yet it lacks the neat touches that make the Mercedes easier to live with when the  roof is down, plus it has weaker residuals.

Most Popular

Driving test update to preserve the manual gearbox
Dacia Duster gear lever
News

Driving test update to preserve the manual gearbox

With more drivers learning in autos and electric cars, the DVSA is looking to update the driving test so people can still drive manuals in future
16 Jun 2021
New Volkswagen ID.4 GTX 2021 review
Volkswagen ID.4 GTX
Volkswagen ID.4 SUV

New Volkswagen ID.4 GTX 2021 review

VW ID.4 EV gets another electric motor and four-wheel drive in hot GTX form
21 Jun 2021
New Volkswagen Caddy California 2021 review
Volkswagen Caddy California MPV - front
Volkswagen Caddy

New Volkswagen Caddy California 2021 review

It’s a family hauler and weekend camper all rolled into one, but is the Volkswagen Caddy California any good?
21 Jun 2021
New Mercedes C-Class 2021 review
Mercedes C-Class - front
Mercedes C-Class

New Mercedes C-Class 2021 review

The new Mercedes C-Class compact exec gets S-Class-inspired tech and new suspension to challenge the BMW 3 Series
21 Jun 2021
UN report highlights ethical problems with electric cars
Electric car charging
News

UN report highlights ethical problems with electric cars

Analysis reveals lithium refining takes 65 per cent of Chilean region’s water, while 40,000 child miners dig for cobalt in DRC
14 Jun 2021
Fiat 500 vs MINI Electric vs Honda e
Fiat 500 vs Honda e vs MINI Electric
Car group tests

Fiat 500 vs MINI Electric vs Honda e

The new Fiat 500, MINI Electric and Honda e are three retro-inspired electric superminis - but which is best?
19 Jun 2021
New 2021 Peugeot 308 SW estate arrives with more space
Peugeot 308 SW - front
News

New 2021 Peugeot 308 SW estate arrives with more space

The Peugeot 308 SW joins the hatchback in the range and arrives with two plug-in hybrid options
22 Jun 2021
New Audi Q4 e-tron 2021 review
Audi Q4 e-tron 2021  front
Audi Q4 e-tron

New Audi Q4 e-tron 2021 review

We get involved with the new all-electric Audi Q4 e-tron SUV on UK roads for the first time
17 Jun 2021
New Dacia Duster facelift launched with fresh styling and more tech
Dacia Duster facelift - front
Dacia Duster

New Dacia Duster facelift launched with fresh styling and more tech

The budget-conscious Dacia Duster has been updated for 2021 with some subtle design tweaks and a new eight-inch infotainment screen
22 Jun 2021
New Skoda Enyaq iV 2021 review
Skoda Enyaq iV 80 Sportline - front
Skoda Enyaq

New Skoda Enyaq iV 2021 review

The new Skoda Enyaq iV is the Czech firm’s first bespoke electric car and we've tested the full range on UK roads
10 Jun 2021
‘The 2030 combustion engine ban is just around the corner – and we’re running out of time’
opinion: charging
Opinion

‘The 2030 combustion engine ban is just around the corner – and we’re running out of time’

Andy Palmer sees electric car uptake revving-up in the UK but says targeted investment is needed to prevent a stall…
22 Jun 2021
Ineos Grenadier prototype 2022 review
Ineos Grenadier prototype
Ineos Grenadier 4x4

Ineos Grenadier prototype 2022 review

Can the Ineos Grenadier really fill the mud-splattered void left by the old Land Rover Defender? We take a first drive in a prototype to find out...
15 Jun 2021
'A top footballer works minutes for his car, but the average worker must graft for 12 months'
Opinion - average car
Opinion

'A top footballer works minutes for his car, but the average worker must graft for 12 months'

Mike Rutherford says it's increasingly easy for them, and far harder for us, to earn enough for our new cars
20 Jun 2021
New Nissan Qashqai 2021 review
Nissan Qashqai 2021
Nissan Qashqai

New Nissan Qashqai 2021 review

We get behind the wheel of the larger, more comfortable and higher-tech Nissan Qashqai SUV in the UK
16 Jun 2021