Hands-free assisted driving megatest: top autonomous car tech tested in the UK
Driver Assistance tech can now chauffeur you hands-off on the motorway. But can seven ADAS-equipped cars master our 37-mile test route that takes in a variety of other roads?
This is Auto Express’s hands-free assisted driving test, part 2 of our ADAS megatest that examines advanced driver safety aids in part 1. We’ve assembled cars from seven brands: Chinese upstarts Leapmotor and Jaecoo, mainstream stalwarts Ford and Volkswagen, leading-edge software and technology providers in Tesla, BMW and Volvo, the latter a brand which built its reputation on safety. All these cars have Level 2 driving capability, which means each understands its environment including the speed limit, can control the pace and distance to the vehicle in front and steer to remain in lane.
The Tesla and Volvo can also change lanes automatically on the motorway, but the Ford has the snazziest party trick: its BlueCruise system is Level 2+, which means we can roll on 70mph motorways with hands off the steering wheel. Nonetheless, with any L2 system, the driver is liable at all times and must stay engaged: these are assistance – not fully autonomous – systems.
The route
We’re running the cars on a 37-mile test route, covering around 10 miles on the M40, another 10 miles along the A422 incorporating those sweeping 50mph bends, plus the A43’s dual carriageway back to our Upper Heyford base.
The loop includes detours through Middleton Cheney, Farthinghoe and Brackley, although none of our cars has ‘L2++’ urban assistance; BMW aims to introduce this from 2027.
Our runs will give a sense of how well prepared different systems are – and their performance across a spectrum of road types. We’ll strive to keep our feet off the pedals, and minimise steering and speed interventions. And we’ll award points to grade the cars on how well they adapt to speed signs and road features such as bends or junctions, how intuitive the systems are to use and how clearly they communicate their status with the driver.
Read on for the unflinching verdict on how the driver-assist technology in each car performed. Then check out part 1 of our ADAS megatest, and the full verdict where we rank today's best ADAS technology.
Jaecoo 7
This two-and-a-half minute rodeo encapsulates the Jaecoo 7’s driver assistance system. Our Chinese ‘chauffeur’ is driving us uphill on a rural road at the 50mph limit, towards a sweeping right bend marked by five chevron arrows. Like a wired slip fielder in cricket, my hands hover over the steering wheel, my feet are poised by the pedals. The car bongs just as I realise it isn’t going to make the turn, so I grip the rim and feed in the lock to ease it round. Phew. After a straight we approach a tighter left: the 7 is too close to the verge, so it corrects and veers onto the central white lines – thankfully no cars are oncoming – then over-corrects back towards the grass.
I glance down at the digital driver’s display to check the speed – only to be gaslit with a ‘You have been distracted’ warning.
My experienced co-tester, Colin Grover of Apollo Vehicle Safety, drily observes that – unlike the other six test cars – the 7 has inundated us with beeps, bongs and messages: Intelligent Cruise Control cancelled! Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) failure, Contact service! Over the 60-minute test loop, we get 30 ACC turned off warnings and 28 driver distraction messages from the Jaecoo, roughly one a minute. Distracting indeed.
We bear down on a roundabout. Mercifully, there’s a Land Rover Defender ahead which the Jaecoo’s forward-distance monitoring clocks, slowing us to 26mph. But then the Defender clears the approach and the 7 starts piling on speed towards the grassy road island. Again I grab the wheel and pivot us into the exit for Brackley. Double phew.
If the Jaecoo 7 was your chauffeur, you’d fire him and drive home yourself. The control logic is unfathomable: a long press on the steering wheel graphic turns on ICA and the blue lane markings – although warning messages confusingly refer to ICC. The driver display’s tiny icons – a grey steering wheel which turns blue when activated, a green speedo (on a pale background!) which occasionally flashes to signal you can deploy intelligent speed assist – are practically invisible, and trigger distraction warnings if you gaze at them.
Unlike the German cars, the Jaecoo is pretty clueless about its surroundings: it reacts to corners, roundabouts or junctions with the awe you’d greet a UFO. Speed limits are equally bewildering: only twice does it automatically adjust to the limit, when I spot its minuscule warning and click the down arrow in time. Otherwise it’s clicking up and down until you reach your desired speed. Jaecoo, just automate this stuff.
Our first major road is the fast, rural B4030, where the Jaecoo barrels towards a tricky 35mph corner at 55, requiring some adroit human intervention. A bit later it slows and steers promisingly approaching a gentle right-hander – then bails out halfway through the turn.
Things stabilise on the motorway and dual carriageway; no surprise for a system engineered for wide Chinese highways, not Northants’ leafy corridors. It’s active for about four minutes on the M40, competently trailing a lorry at a safe distance, but suspends the steering assist during lane changes, expecting the driver to settle the car between the white lines before re-engaging.
Heading back to base, the A43 stretch features some heroically late braking at a couple of roundabouts, punctuated with requests for me to ‘Take over the vehicle’ – a reassuring jab of steering calms the 7 down. If only it was that simple for my blood pressure, following that run.
Leapmotor B10
The Leapmotor B10 must have been born in the year of the pig – it keeps launching itself at the verge like a hog sniffing out truffles. Of the seven cars, it’s by far the worst for lane control, frequently failing to determine the road boundaries, fading them in and out on the digital driver’s display.
Triggering the active cruise and lane-centring controls requires a double yank of the gear
selector, old school Tesla-style. But activation is so haphazard, there are times when I’m pulling it like a one-armed bandit addict in a Vegas casino. Thankfully, speed adaptation is by rotary wheel, which is simpler than the Jaecoo’s buttons.
But like the Jaecoo 7, the Leapmotor is hopeless at bends on country roads. Despite tailing a SEAT that slows the B10 to 37mph, I have to dive in to haul it around the corner that also flummoxed its compatriot. During the 50mph sweepers either side of Farthinghoe, it fluffs two turns, wanders around in its lane like a drunken sailor, then ultimately goes on strike, with the LCC refusing to re-engage for ages.
Part of the problem is that steering interventions can switch off the system, as we find on the M40. To stay on course at 70mph, the steering column is so torqued up that any inputs are like opening a rusty submarine hatch. The upside is that it resolutely stays in lane, with the system suspending during a manual lane change, then kicking back in once I’ve repositioned the electric car.
The B10 settles into an underwhelming pattern on the A43: it approaches roundabouts at unsettlingly high speeds, then after we circumnavigate the hazard refuses to automatically kick back in. While its peers all tap out during roundabouts, twice the B10 tries to intervene and follow the first exit. Closing in on Upper Heyford, after it flunks a few more curves and dices with multiple verges, I switch off the system and drive manually. Beaten by the B10. Although it did a nice job of spotting a cyclist in a 60mph zone.
Ford Puma
We’re rolling along the M40 at 70mph, so I let go of the wheel and wave jazz hands at Colin. Instead of disapproval from one of Britain’s foremost road safety testers, he just grins; the Puma Gen-E has BlueCruise, one of the first L2+ hands-off systems – which Colin assessed in the United States during its development.
The Puma offers us BlueCruise shortly after entering this ‘blue-signed’ highway; I press confirm and nothing happens. Another press, then the display shows a big blue steering wheel. Seems the Puma was reviewing its surroundings and my eyes on the road before enacting hands-off control, graphically communicated by two thick blue lines either side of the Puma.
Having waved like a royal, what else can my hands do with this unprecedented freedom? After picking up my sunglasses from the footwell and having a sip of water from a bottle, I’ve exhausted my options so it’s lane-change time – a resolutely hands-on affair.
Otherwise the Puma is a pretty limited co-pilot. It responds to corners like a vampire to sunlight, with more chimes than electronic music pioneers Orbital and ‘cancelled: sharp curve’ warnings after slowing for our tight initial bends and the 50mph sweepers – it only self-drives one of these. And the Ford is easily flummoxed by irregular lane markings: “This is a car which wants a well defined lane, and knows its limits,” says Colin.
But it makes a reasonable fist of responding to speed limit changes, blending into the background when it can’t cope before re-engaging. Also, steering inputs feel fluid rather than making it seem like you’re battling a locked steering column. The control pad, with an old-school toggle to set the speed and clear lane and distance markings, is super clear, too.
Volvo EX60
Volvo’s reputation is built on safety, setting the bar high for the EX60’s Pilot Assist. Promisingly, its readout is the best on test, with the driver’s display building a confidence-boosting picture of surrounding traffic and clearly communicating lane markings, bends and feedback – and it’s high up in your direct line of vision.
However, activation has taken a step backwards from the EX90’s simple gear selector-pull to engage Pilot Assist. The EX60 has a four-directional toggle for speed and distance control, with a speedo graphic in the middle, plus a separate steering-wheel button. Rather than having Colin Grover in the passenger seat, I could do with Alan Turing to crack the code of which order to press them.
We get the system running, but the EX60 is fidgety in lane and – despite automatically dropping to 25mph for our challenging first bend – needs help to execute the turn. Also, we’re struggling to get the Volvo to react to speed limit changes, eventually deducing they must be accepted – quickly – with a push up on the steering toggle. A faff we don’t just don’t get in the BMW or VW.
The EX60 has semi-automated lane changes (Auto Pilot scans for free lanes and offers you a dotted box to move into when you indicate) but it’s like watching one of David Blaine’s magic tricks go wrong. In its defence, the Volvo faces the heaviest showers of our test, but it keeps offering M40 overtakes then cancelling them – sometimes in the middle of my manoeuvre – even when there’s sufficient room. Ultimately it nails just 32 per cent of our 25 attempts.
“I’m seeing many opportunities available, but you spend a lot of time interacting with the car to take them rather than just making the lane changes yourself,” is Colin’s verdict. The flipside is while I am totally consumed by the lane changes, the Volvo is rock solid at staying in lane and keeping back from the vehicle ahead.
And things improve: the Volvo doesn’t miss a beat on the A422, acing every 50mph curve. Then the pace picks up to 70mph on the A43: the EX60 slows to a conservative speed for roundabouts and communicates that ‘steering assist is not available’ as we enter them.
Tesla Model Y
If safety defines Volvo, then modern Tesla is built on AI-enabled autonomy. YouTube is stuffed with videos showing ‘Full Self-Driving (Supervised)’ Teslas zooming around US roads, from the awe-inspiring to video nasties.
But Europe is different: the system is constrained to Level 2 capability, and labelled Tesla Assisted Driving (TAD) so owners are under no illusion that their car can self-drive. And its attempt at collaborative driving is as collegiate as Elon Musk’s people management at DOGE.
The playbook is this: engage TAD with the steering’s right clickwheel, watch two blue lines fence in the Model Y on the touchscreen’s impressive recreation of its environment, then
sigh as the system stroppily disengages as soon as I try to help steer. It jacks it in six times over the six miles to the M40, including the fast right/left that has bamboozled almost all of our test cars, as well as the gentler sweeper that hasn’t, on this occasion with the added spice of an oncoming MAN lorry. Rural lane control is at times erratic, and it charges into the Ardley 30mph zone at 60.
On the motorway, however, the Tesla is very good. We dabble with veering off road, and trigger a clear driver attention warning, then blissfully follow an HGV for a couple of minutes. And it sets the standard for automated lane changes, with TAD nailing three out of four manoeuvres. “It’s a lot less fussy than the Volvo; put the turn signal on and it just smoothly goes,” judges Colin.
Performance is more hit-and-miss on the A422’s curves. The steering feels as if rigor mortis has set in, and the camera-only system often positions the Model Y too tight to the verge, meaning it has to back off mid-corner. Twice I have to intervene – and the system packs in. But ‘curvature assist’ does nail the last five bends – despite me losing faith in its lane positioning and entry speeds.
It’s a similar story on the A43, with two lane changes cancelling the system (and one switch successfully automated), but it’s a touch conservative accelerating up to the speed limit.
Volkswagen T-Roc
What is this witchcraft? VW’s humble T-Roc is the only car to ace our first challenging corner because it anticipates the hazard and brakes to 25mph – although it then fails to make the following left-hander. Thank our test car’s optional £1,045 Technology Pack, incorporating Travel Assist, which adds predictive cruise control and assisted lane change.
Its crystal-clear control pack feels crafted by painstaking German logic: the MODE button cycles through your cruise control options,
SET locks in the speed and RES brings it back in after a hiatus. And the T-Roc makes a decent fist of the pre-M40 rural stretch, telegraphing upcoming road features, slightly late on just one speed limit change and communicating clearly – BRAKE! – when it wants me to intervene at a junction. Its only minor infraction is wobbling around in lane.
The T-Roc glides onto the M40 and flashes up ‘Travel Assist With Assisted Lane Changing available’. Excitedly I pull the indicator – and nothing happens. So I indicate again and nudge the steering right: zero response. There’s a small lane graphic in the driver’s display offering me arrows and little blue cars, but I can’t determine what’s me and what’s passing traffic. I look in the side mirror – which would activate an BMW iX3 – and click buttons, merely to get told to pay attention to the road. The T-Roc’s instructional clarity is clouded, and my eight attempts end in failure.
Things continue to go amiss on the A422, with the VW being very late to slow from 50mph to 30 for Middleton Cheney. But unlike the other test cars, the VW doesn’t wave the white flag in built-up areas: it works with me as I steer around a parked Citroen C1 and brakes for an upcoming parked van, with control passing fluidly between car and driver.
It also drives competently and briskly through the sweeper sections, so confident in one corner that the gearbox kicks down and it accelerates. It occasionally requests I ‘take over steering’ which isn’t a cry for help, more confirmation that I haven’t gone to sleep. Which I almost could: I haven’t touched the pedals for miles.
BMW iX3
BMW’s iX3 is – like the Volvo and Tesla – a Software Defined Vehicle, with an incredibly fast-acting, centralised computing stack. Neue Klasse BMWs introduce next-level assisted driving, with the car taking responsibility for more of the decision-making. Sophisticated driver monitoring assesses the pilot’s intentions – such as briefly crossing the central line to overtake a cyclist – and will allow the action if it won’t imperil surrounding traffic. Specify the £925 Driving Assistant Plus and the iX3 can execute automated motorway lane changes, triggered by the driver looking in the mirror to check the blindspot. Clever.
Operating the Driving Assistant is simple: just press one translucent button on the steering wheel. There are supplementary speed adjustment buttons but, spoiler alert, we didn’t need them. Up pops up an ‘Assisted Driving Activated’ message on the Panoramic iDrive digital strip, along with green lane markings and steering wheel graphic. The BMW communicates with the sophistication of a supersmooth diplomat. That said, the digital rendering of your environment is relegated to the touchscreen, unlike in the Volvo.
Throughout our hour-long journey, the BMW nails every speed limit sign, accelerating or braking to the new limit just as we cross the threshold. It also cross-checks with the in-car mapping or even your indicators, to help slow the car for bends and junctions.
Not that it manages to self-drive through our first two curves: the green wheel graphic turns amber and I feed in some lock to stop us clipping the first verge. The iX3 doesn’t fight my inputs; it’s a system BMW calls ‘symbiotic’ and it rapidly resumes lane guidance. “The car is building a mental model of its competence, saying ‘I’m not doing everything for you, but I will support and encourage cornering’,” decodes Colin. The M40 stretch in light rain is uneventful.
Our car doesn’t have the upgraded system, so triggers a warning if your hands are off the wheel for six seconds and flashes red graphics after 20 seconds. Although I’ve experienced the iX3’s eye-tracking-triggered overtakes before, I have to settle for manual lane changes, with the assistance slackening off then solidly re-engaging once I’m in lane.
For the A422 sweepers, I feel like I’m in Strictly Come Dancing, with the BMW sometimes waltzing me through the curves, while sometimes I’m leading. And my only objection to iX-pilot on the 70mph A43 is its conservative braking distances ahead of roundabouts, when it momentarily blends out before re-engaging after the junction and powering up once more.
Final verdict
This test is a rebuttal to anyone who says all new cars feel the same, with the Chinese cars obviously streets behind their European counterparts.
The illogical Jaecoo 7 ranks last: our drive is an hour-long tug of war where I attempt to turn on the system and the 7 promptly turns it off again, punctuated by around 100 warning messages. The Leapmotor B10’s weakness is its lane control and apathetic steering response, but it lets you know where you stand. Its driving assistance is strictly for motorways.
Next up is the one-trick pony Puma, which admittedly has one hell of a trick. For £29,545 (including Electric Car Grant), the Gen-E BlueCruise Edition cruises hands-off on the highway – but it won’t do much elsewhere.
Separating the final four is tougher. The Volvo EX60 is cautious but capable and – largely – a good communicator. “It gives you no impression this is a self-driving car,” says Colin approvingly, although it offers convincing support on a wide range of roads. However, complex controls mean it narrowly misses out on the podium.
The Tesla takes the bronze. It’s almost as simple to use as the BMW and aces the motorway section with its effortless lane changes. But it could really use a head-up display, with error messages communicated somewhere near the driver’s knees. And its steering behaviour is incredibly binary. “Some things it delivers so well,” says Colin, “but when support breaks down, it spectacularly refuses to work with you.”
As for the VW, the T-Roc rocks. Aside from the AWOL assisted lane change, dodgy lane centring and odd speed limit slacking off, the VW was a revelation and even partially helped in town. But the BMW is our favourite assisted driving system. It nailed every speed limit change, lane position and was a dream to use.
Since completing this test, I’ve started using my Volvo EX90’s Pilot Assist on every motorway journey: it’s so relaxing to know there’s an electronic guardian angel helping me stay in lane and away from the vehicle in front. And the BMW iX3 takes assisted driving to an even higher level: you could leave it on at all times as an unobtrusive safety net. And one of these days you, or other road users, might be very grateful that you did.
| Position | Make/model | Controls, communication, logic, monitoring | Motorway, distance, braking, lane change | Response to to road layout/speed adaptation | Steering/collaboration, lane control | Total |
| 1st | BMW iX3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 18/20 |
| 2nd | Volkswagen T-Roc | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 16/20 |
| 3rd | Tesla Model Y | 4 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 16/20 |
| 4th | Volvo EX60 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 15/20 |
| 5th | Ford Puma Gen-E Bluecruise | 5 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 15/20 |
| 6th= | Leapmotor B10 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 6/20 |
| 6th= | Jaecoo 7 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 6/20 |
More from our ADAS car safety special
- ADAS warning and safety tech tested (part 1)
- Hands-free self driving systems tested (part 2)
- Best and worst ADAS 2026/2027: megatest verdict
Don't miss the best of Auto Express on Google! Make us a preferred source. Click here...




