Car group tests

Car group tests

The UK's most popular cars head-to-head against their key rivals...

If you really want to know how a car performs against its key rivals, this is the place to find out. The Auto Express group test is an automotive institution decades in the making that gets right to the heart of the questions that car buyers want answered. 

While our in-depth reviews and long-term tests are usually done with the car in isolation, albeit by experienced journalists with detailed prior experience of hundreds of other cars, the group test puts two or three direct rivals head-to-head in the same place, on the same roads and in the same conditions. There is nowhere to hide. 

As a means of slimming down your car buying shortlist these exhaustive tests are great. We drive the cars over long distances, interrogate the control systems, load and unload the interiors, and take our own precise measurements to make comparisons easier. Sometimes there’s an obvious winner but often what emerges is a picture of two cars with qualities that would suit different kinds of buyer - a picture that only becomes clear after this kind of detailed side-by-side testing. 

Our team brings you at least one two- or three-car group test every week, building up a clear picture of the cars we rate and those that we don’t... 

Scroll down to find all our group test pages… 

New & used car deals

Dacia Spring

Dacia Spring

RRP £14,995Avg. savings £6,462 off RRP*
MG MG4

MG MG4

RRP £27,005Avg. savings £10,201 off RRP*Used from £10,200
Volkswagen Polo

Volkswagen Polo

RRP £15,255Avg. savings £1,912 off RRP*Used from £7,299
Omoda 5

Omoda 5

RRP £23,990Avg. savings £1,429 off RRP*
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

More on Car group tests

Peugeot vs Volkswagen
Peugeot v VW

Peugeot vs Volkswagen

Peugeot’s new turbocharged 308 has upmarket aspirations. but can it match the premium class quality of the Volkswagen golf? We find out...
Car group tests
6 Feb 2008
Jaguar XF vs rivals
luxury front

Jaguar XF vs rivals

Jaguar hopes to shake up the executive sector with the new XF. We find out if it can beat its key rivals.
Car group tests
6 Feb 2008
Fiesta v Clio v Corsa
Fiat etc

Fiesta v Clio v Corsa

A racy upgrade promises to transform Ford’s flagship performance supermini. but does it deliver? we find out as the new ST185 meets its Renault and Va…
Car group tests
30 Jan 2008
V8 Vantage vs GranTurismo vs XKR
Aston Vantage Maserati XKR

V8 Vantage vs GranTurismo vs XKR

We head to France to see if the all-new Aston Martin V8 Vantage N400 and Maserati GranTurismo can beat Jaguar’s XKR to be crowned the ultimate grand t…
Car group tests
23 Jan 2008
Perodua vs Mazda
Perodua Myvi, Mazda 2

Perodua vs Mazda

Perodua has traditionally been unable to challenge the best superminis, and focused instead on being the champ of cheap new cars. Is its new Myvi good…
Car group tests
23 Jan 2008
Mercedes C-Class vs BMW 3-Series
Mercedes C-Class vs BMW 3-Series

Mercedes C-Class vs BMW 3-Series

It looks great, and it's roomy, too... But can Mercedes' new C-Class Estate topple the new BMW 3-Series Touring as we put the pair head-to-head?
Car group tests
16 Jan 2008
Mazda 6 vs Ford Mondeo vs Volkswagen Passat
Mazda 6 vs Ford Mondeo vs Volkswagen Passat

Mazda 6 vs Ford Mondeo vs Volkswagen Passat

After the success of its first-generation 6, Mazda believes it has moved the game on again with the new model. But has it improved enough to beat the …
Car group tests
16 Jan 2008
207 SW Outdoor vs Roomster Scout
Header shot

207 SW Outdoor vs Roomster Scout

Peugeot has given its 207 SW a rugged new look. But is the outdoor model a tempting proposition? We find out as it goes head-to-head with Skoda’s Room…
Car group tests
9 Jan 2008
Audi A3 vs BMW 116i vs Mercedes A170
Audi A3 vs BMW 116i vs Mercedes A170

Audi A3 vs BMW 116i vs Mercedes A170

You don’t have to spend massive amounts of money to get behind the wheel of a Mercedes, Audi or BMW. Here we try three sub-£18,000 models from the Ger…
Car group tests
9 Jan 2008
Laguna Sport Tourer vs rivals
Laguna, Accord, Mondeo

Laguna Sport Tourer vs rivals

Renault's new Laguna Sport Tourer is leading the firm’s drive upmarket. But is it good enough to beat established stars, the Honda Accord and Ford Mon…
Car group tests
2 Jan 2008
Mercedes CLS vs BMW 6-Series Coupe
Mercedes CLS and BMW 6-Series

Mercedes CLS vs BMW 6-Series Coupe

BMW has finally added a diesel to the 6-Series range. We compare it to the oil-burning CLS to see which makes the better grand tourer.
Car group tests
2 Jan 2008
Cool cabrios
Saab 9-3 cabrio v VW Eos

Cool cabrios

Run a cabrio in winter? You must be joking! We see how Saab’s new 9-3 convertible and Volkswagen's Eos shape up as all-year all-rounders
Car group tests
21 Dec 2007
Skip advert
Advertisement
Renault Clio vs Fiat Grande Punto vs Mazda 2
Clio, 2, Grande Punto

Renault Clio vs Fiat Grande Punto vs Mazda 2

Do turbocharged engines make sense in superminis? Fiat thinks so, and has just fitted one into its latest Grande Punto. We see how it fares against Re…
Car group tests
19 Dec 2007
Top tests '07

Top tests '07

We put the best cars head-to-head each week. Here we look back at the highlights of the year...
Car group tests
12 Dec 2007
4X4 Mega test
4X4 mega test

4X4 Mega test

In an Auto Express first, we line up 12 off-roaders, from premium SUV to Pick-up truck, and pit them against the toughest 4x4 course in the country to…
Car group tests
5 Dec 2007
Ford Focus vs Honda Civic
Focus vs Civic

Ford Focus vs Honda Civic

Ford’s new Focus is here – and desperate to reclaim its Position at the top of the compact family car class. In this first head-to-head test, we see i…
Car group tests
5 Dec 2007
Diesel vs petrol roadsters

Diesel vs petrol roadsters

Is diesel the best choice for a roadster? We find out as the new Alfa Spider JTDM meets the petrol-powered Audi TT 2.0
Car group tests
28 Nov 2007
Fuel economy challenge
Economy header

Fuel economy challenge

We find out how much difference changing your driving style can make to your fuel bills on motorways, country roads and in town...
Car group tests
27 Nov 2007
Subaru Impreza twin test
Impreza WRX vs Civic Type R

Subaru Impreza twin test

Subaru’s new hatchback Impreza has already divided opinion. But is the first hot version, the WRX, a match for the Honda Civic Type R?
Car group tests
21 Nov 2007
Kia Picanto v rival

Kia Picanto v rival

Its predecessor was one of the UK's top-selling city cars. So is Kia’s new Picanto just as tempting? We find out as it meets Peugeot's 107
Car group tests
14 Nov 2007
Renault Laguna test
Renault Laguna group

Renault Laguna test

Can Renault’s new Laguna teach its competitors a thing or two about family cars? We find out as it meets the Ford Mondeo and Peugeot 407 in its first …
Car group tests
14 Nov 2007
Lexus LS600h vs Audi A8
Lexus vs Audi

Lexus LS600h vs Audi A8

The new Lexus lS600h hybrid aims to blend performance and luxury with class-leading efficiency. Can it beat Audi’s diesel-engined A8L?
Car group tests
7 Nov 2007
MINI Clubman vs rivals
MINI Clubman vs rivals

MINI Clubman vs rivals

Road test editor Oliver Marriage and family try the new MINI Clubman for size. We find out if it’s as versatile as the Peugeot 207 SW – and enough of …
Car group tests
7 Nov 2007