Honda e:Ny1 Advance long-term test: EV's winter range is sub-par at best

I’ve been racking up the miles in the Honda e:Ny1 and, as a result, I’ve been spending plenty of time at public chargepoints. It’s supposed to charge up to 78kW, but the most juice I’ve seen it suck in is a rather disappointing 57kW. It wouldn’t be such an issue if it didn’t need to be topped up so often, but it only has a real-world range of 125 miles in the winter. Any sort of longer trip requires a one-hour stop for every two hours of driving. Not great!

Honda e:Ny1 Advance: second report

While the giant touchscreen and the tech behind it are major highlights, the Honda e:Ny1 continues to be held back by its poor efficiency and high running costs.

• Efficiency: 2.2 miles/kWh
• Mileage: 7,455

The Honda e:Ny1 has a party piece that never fails to impress. I’ve heard the words “wow, look at the size of that screen” from almost everyone who has sat inside, and there’s no denying that the giant 15.1-inch portrait display dominates the cabin.

Although its size is impressive, the more I use it, the more I appreciate its brilliance. I’ve read some owners have been slightly disappointed that the screen can’t just show one huge sat-nav map etc, and is instead only able to be used in three separate parts, but that’s exactly what makes it stand out to me.

Used - available now

2022 Kia

e-Niro

65,342 milesAutomaticElectric

Cash £14,087

View e-Niro

2023 Land Rover

Range Rover Evoque

49,875 milesAutomaticPetrol1.5L

Cash £28,487

View Range Rover Evoque

2023 Land Rover

Range Rover Evoque

17,669 milesAutomaticPetrol1.5L

Cash £30,400

View Range Rover Evoque

2021 Tesla

Model 3

33,412 milesAutomaticElectric

Cash £17,800

View Model 3

The top third is either your navigation or Apple CarPlay/Android Auto control. The middle section displays media, car settings and other menu options, while the bottom portion is solely for the climate controls. This means that everything is at your fingertips when you need it. There’s no prodding away at the screen trying to find the correct menu to change the radio station while you’re on the move – it’s all right there and ready to go.

Another huge advantage is that you can double up on Apple CarPlay. If you’re using Google Maps for navigation, you can keep all the information on the top screen, while changing the podcast you’re listening to on the middle section. It’s a very handy feature.

I’m amazed other car companies haven’t done something similar. There’s a constant debate in the Auto Express office about the merits of touchscreens and physical controls, but it feels like the e:Ny1 provides the best of both worlds. It’s perhaps not quite as simple as turning a dial, but it’s the next best thing.

27

While the screen has been a great asset, the Honda really does suffer from an Achilles’ heel. As I mentioned in my first report (below), I was shocked at how inefficient it is, and it’s got worse as winter has taken hold. With temperatures regularly plummeting below zero recently, the e:Ny1 has gone from averaging 2.6 miles/kWh during its time with me so far to just 2.2 miles/kWh. In fact, because I was keen to know just how bad it is, I reset one of the trip computers… then watched, alarmed, as it dropped to 1.6 miles/kWh on a particularly cold morning.

As a result, I’m having to carefully plan longer journeys and resort to regular public charging, something I’d managed to mostly avoid in the past. On a recent trip to Cardiff from West London, I had to stop three times for a top-up. Thankfully there were charging bays available each time, but this highlighted another of the Honda’s issues – charging speed. It can only draw in a maximum of 78kW, so I’ve spent a lot of time waiting around for the battery to be replenished.

Lots of public charging also means it’s costing me significantly more to run than I anticipated. I’ve calculated I’m paying around 40p per mile thanks to a real-world range of around 125 miles and charging costs of 79p/kWh. So much for low EV running costs! I’ve had numerous E-mails from readers complaining of similar issues and how it’s costing them so much more to run than they expected. Most sign off by stating they won’t return to EV power any time soon.

To highlight the issue, senior photographer Pete Gibson is currently running a Skoda Superb diesel, and he’s getting 800 miles from a full tank – meaning running costs of less than 12p per mile (thanks to a 66-litre 
fuel tank and £1.44 per litre diesel prices). It just goes to show the difference!

The e:Ny1 was due to go back to Honda after three months with us, but I feel it deserves a second chance during potentially warmer weather. The firm has agreed to an extension, so let’s see what spring brings and if the car can get closer to its official 256-mile range.

Honda e:Ny1 Advance: first fleetwatch

27

The Honda e:Ny1's boot size trails rivals such as the Hyundai Kona Electric

I’m preparing for a house move, so the Honda e:Ny1 has been helping me to palm off all the tat I no longer want on unsuspecting friends and family. However, it’s become clear that the Honda’s boot is really rather small. At just 344 litres, it’s way down on some of its electric SUV rivals, such as the Hyundai Kona Electric (466 litres). Add a few boxes and a couple of bags and it’s bursting at the seams, meaning multiple trips are often needed.

Honda e:Ny1 Advance: first report

27

We like many aspects of life with Honda’s electric family SUV, but its disappointing efficiency is a cause for concern

• Efficiency: 2.6 miles/kWh
• Mileage: 5,180

Hear the words ‘electric car’ in a conversation and it’s not long before the word ‘range’ is mentioned, because many people are fixated on just how far EVs will go on a single charge.

I have been an electric convert for the past couple of years, though, and as a result it’s something that has worried me less and less over time, especially as many modern cars now have bigger batteries and are, in theory, becoming more efficient. The more you drive an EV, the more you get used to how they perform and plan journeys accordingly. Range anxiety is almost a thing of the past.

But I’m now finding range dominating my thoughts once again and it’s all down to the latest arrival on our fleet: the Honda e:Ny1. Before taking the keys, I was quite pleased to see it boasted an official WLTP figure of

256 miles from its 62kWh battery, and was looking forward to taking plenty of stress-free trips to see family and friends down the M40 motorway. But the reality is quite different.

When the e:Ny1 was delivered, I plugged it in and left it to fully charge. A few hours later, I was quite surprised to see the quoted range showing just 183 miles. Where did those 73 miles go? I thought the figure would surely start to rise with some careful driving around town. But instead of improving, the situation has become even worse.

I’ve now been driving the Honda for a couple of weeks, covering more than 500 miles in the process, and it’s only returned 2.6 miles per kWh so far. If it continues like that, I can expect a range of just over 160 miles in reality.

27

It’s no secret that electric cars regularly fail to get close to WLTP figures, but it’s not always the case. Chief sub-editor Andy Pringle, for example, is currently running a Genesis GV60, and he recently managed to achieve almost 6.0 miles per kWh on a trip through London. That’s more than double what I’m getting and a figure I can only dream of!

If the e:Ny1 is this inefficient now, what will it be like when the colder weather hits? Will I have enough range to even get to Oxford and back from my home in West London (a trip of just over 100 miles) without having to stop for a top-up? All questions I’ll be answering over the coming months, but it’s certainly left a fair few doubts in my mind.

I contacted Honda to see if the figures I am seeing are an anomaly. I was told: “This sounds about right and to be expected due to the time of year and ambient temperature, causing the battery efficiency to drop off slightly.”

But it feels a little harsh to focus so hard on the e:Ny1’s efficiency, because it’s otherwise been a great car. I really like the way it looks and, although the colour has caused some debate, the overall design is modern. It’s very distinguishable as a Honda, but that’s no bad thing, with so many other bland SUVs around.

With a family of four, I was also pleasantly surprised with the space on offer, especially in the back. Rear legroom is impressive, with a big area for the kids to swing their legs around without kicking the front seats. The illusion of space is also helped by the airy cabin.

The glass roof lets people in the front and back bask in the sunshine when it appears. The only niggle is that the rear section has removable cover panels, rather than a rolling blind. They are slightly fiddly to take out.

In general, the interior quality feels good, with lots of soft-touch materials and no hints of any creaks or rattles, although the piano- black materials used around the centre console are already showing signs of wear.

The showstopper is undoubtedly the huge 15.1-inch central portrait screen. Although I’m not a fan of touchscreens in general, the Honda’s is a fine example of how to do it right, with everything available at your fingertips. There’s no need to scroll through menus while driving to turn the heater up, for instance.

*Insurance quote from AA (0800 107 0680) for a 42-year-old in Banbury, Oxon, with three points.