Advertisement
Best cars & vans

Top 10 most reliable family cars 2020

What are the most reliable family cars you can buy today? Our Driver Power survey reveals all...

Need something practical and economical with enough room to carry the kids? Then you’re in the market for a new family car, and high up your list of requirements will be something that’s crucial to any car ownership experience but always tricky to determine - reliability. 

The last thing any motorist wants is a breakdown but the whole experience just gets worse when you’ve got a gaggle of unhappy children in the back seats. That’s why reliability is key for any car aimed at families and to help you find the right one, we’ve rounded up the most reliable family cars you can buy using data from our 2020 Driver Power survey

There are no guarantees that any car will be reliable. However, information about the experience other motorists have had with the same cars and knowing of any specific faults or issues is a good way to determine how reliable your new purchase will be after you’ve parted with your hard-earned cash. Using data from Driver Power, the UK's biggest car customer satisfaction survey, we can provide an insight into real-world reliability of new family cars that you’ll find hard to match elsewhere.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Our data below reveals the top 10 new family cars for reliability according to the people who own them. We also include the percentage of owners who said they’d experienced a fault of any kind, even if these were relatively minor. The data used is focused on the first 12-months of ownership so it shows how reliable these models are in that initial period, which is also a good indication of how things will pan out later on…

Here are the 10 most reliable family cars in reverse order...

The top 10 most reliable new cars

10. Lexus NX - 95.74%

  • Model: Mk1 (2014-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 11.5%

Spoiler alert! Lexus features prominently in this list and NX owners have been singing the praises of the compact SUV’s reliability. The NX was voted the most reliable car overall in 2018 and finished sixth last year so it’s unsurprising to see it perform well in 2020. Only 11.5 per cent of owners reported a fault.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Overall build quality was slightly less impressive with the NX coming 18th with a score of 93.46 per cent. A middling 42nd-place finish in the overall best cars to own list suggests the NX does have its weak points but reliability isn’t one. 

9. Lexus IS - 95.89%

  • Model: Mk3 (2013-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 14.5%
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Last year’s runner-up in the most reliable family cars category, the Lexus IS has dropped down the pecking order and sits ninth in most reliable family cars list for 2020. The Japanese saloon also just missed out on the overall top ten cars in 2020 with an 11th-placed finish. 

The third-generation IS has been on sale since 2013 and with Lexus offering three-year or 60,000 mile warranty (five years for hybrid versions), there are plenty of IS models on the market out of warranty. New buyers needn’t worry, with only 14.5 per cent reporting faults in the first year. Overall build quality remains a strong suit with a score of 94% and the IS has a 95.89% overall score for reliability. Electrics are most prone to failure when an IS does go wrong, but with Lexus’ first-place finish in Driver Power’s manufacturer survey, the repair process should be fairly painless. 

8. Toyota C-HR  - 95.95% 

  • Model: Mk1 (2016-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 14.3%
Advertisement - Article continues below

The Toyota C-HR makes it into the top 10 family cars list this year and is the first of three Toyota models in this list. With a solid overall reliability score of 95.95%, reported electrical faults from owners prevented the crossover from placing any higher. The C-HR’s 19th place for build quality is strong, as is the 25th-place finish in the overall Driver Power survey. 

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

The number of owners who experienced faults was a relatively low 9.6% and if your Toyota C-HR does go wrong, the brand’s sixth-place in our overall manufacturers table will be reassuring. 

7. Toyota Corolla - 96.06% 

  • Model: Mk12 (2019-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 7.7%

The new Toyota Corolla is not only a return of the Corolla name to UK showrooms but its return also signals a new entry into the reliability top ten. With an overall reliability score of 96.06%, the Corolla has done very well this time out, with interior troubles the biggest issue. The Corolla came an impressive seventh in the overall best cars list, so it’s not only reliability where the hatchback performs well. 

6. Peugeot 3008 - 96.09%

  • Model: Mk2 (2016-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 11.8%
Advertisement - Article continues below

Recall issues were the main gripes mentioned by Peugeot 3008 owners, which is why it still holds strong against tough Japanese competition. In fact Peugeot is the only European brand to enter the top ten list this year. The 3008 managed seventh-place overall in 2019 and has risen to second-place in the overall 2020 ‘best cars to own’ rankings thanks to a score of 92.04%. Despite the 3008 being on sale since 2016, owners are still impressed with overall build quality, giving the French SUV a score 96.09%. 

5. Toyota Prius - 96.56% 

  • Model: Mk4 (2015-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 6.8%
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Last year’s winner has taken a tumble this year. The Prius has fallen down to fifth place in the reliable family cars section and sixth place overall with a score of 96.56%. Toyota’s best known hybrid remains the brand’s highest placed model here. The popular Prius did suffer a few issues with 6.8% of owners having problems but 40 per cent of the issues reported were down to electrical faults. A 16th-placed finish overall in Driver Power 2020 highlights how accomplished the Toyota Prius still is. 

4. Lexus RX - 96.60% 

  • Model: Mk4 (2015-present) 
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 9%
Advertisement - Article continues below

The Lexus RX luxury SUV takes 4th place with a respectable score of 96.60%. Only 9.0% of owners reported issues and those were mainly electrical problems while the RX also came fifth overall for build quality. The record of the Lexus RX in the Driver Power rankings is impressive with a third place finish in 2020’s overall list it’s clearly a car that owners like. 

3. Lexus CT - 96.80% 

  • Model: Mk1 (2011-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 13.9%

The third most reliable family car you can buy now is the Lexus CT - impressive given the model’s long lifespan. For build quality, the Lexus CT sits in fourth place, just missing out on a podium position but beating its bigger SUV sibling, the RX. Only 13.9% of owners reported problems with their CTs but there seemed to be no clear pattern behind the faults. The Lexus CT performed well in the overall Driver Power survey with the premium Japanese hatch coming 19th.

2. Nissan LEAF - 97.04% 

  • Model: Mk2 (2017-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 22.6%
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

The second-generation Nissan LEAF is doing a superb job of showing motorists that electric cars can be reliable and the silver medal position here should help convince motorists that they can have long term faith in EVs. 22.6% of owners reported faults and electrical glitches were the most common but the high reliability score suggested they were minor. The Nissan performs well for overall build quality, gaining a score of 97.04% taking it to third place in that category. A 24th-place finish in the overall Driver Power survey results is also very respectable. 

1. Subaru Outback - 97.24%

  • Model: Mk3 (2015-present)
  • Has it ever gone wrong? 13.5%

The Outback is flying the flag for Subaru this year as it becomes the most reliable family car money can buy. The rough and ready 4x4 only had 13.5% of owners report a problem, with two fifths of those issues being related to the electrics. This is not too bad considering that many Outbacks are see a tough life where their rugged 4x4 mechanicals are used regularly off road . An overall reliability score of 97.24% will be reassuring for new buyers, as will Subaru’s third-place on our best manufacturers of 2020 list. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

Most reliable family cars top 20

Below you’ll find the full list of Driver Power’s most reliable family cars for 2020.

Ranking

Model

Reliability score

1

Subaru Outback Mk3

97.24%

2

Nissan LEAF Mk2

97.04%

3

Lexus CT Mk1

96.80%

4

Lexus RX Mk4

96.60%

5

Toyota Prius Mk4

96.56%

6

Peugeot 3008 Mk2

96.09%

7

Toyota Corolla Mk12

96.06%

8

Toyota C-HR Mk1

95.95%

9

Lexus IS Mk3

95.89%

10

Lexus NX Mk1

95.74%

11

Toyota RAV4 Mk5

95.71%

12

Subaru XV Mk2

95.66%

13

Mazda CX-5 Mk2

95.52%

14

Volvo XC60 Mk2

95.15%

15

Suzuki Vitara Mk4

95.05%

16

Mazda 6 Mk3

95.03%

17

SEAT Leon Mk3

94.95%

18

Skoda Superb Mk3

94.74%

19

Citroën C4 Grand Space Tourer Mk1

94.72%

20

Kia Sportage Mk4

94.47%

Click below to find out the most reliable cars by sector... 

Click here to take our Driver Power customer satisfaction survey right now...

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

Best cars to own: Driver Power 2020 results
Driver Power

Best cars to own: Driver Power 2020 results

UK owners deliver their verdict on long-term life with the latest cars as part of our Driver Power 2020 customer satisfaction survey
8 Apr 2020
Driver Power
driver power header
Driver Power

Driver Power

Driver Power is the UK’s number one car customer satisfaction survey and in 2020 it was bigger and better than ever. 
26 Feb 2020
The best cars for comfort, tech, safety and more
Best cars & vans

The best cars for comfort, tech, safety and more

Driver Power, the UK’s most comprehensive car customer satisfaction survey, crowns the winning cars in eight different categories
5 May 2020
Most reliable 4x4s and SUVs 2020
Driver Power

Most reliable 4x4s and SUVs 2020

We reveal the most reliable 4x4s and SUVs you can buy according to the 2020 Driver Power survey
4 May 2020

Most Popular

SEAT Leon vs Volkswagen Golf vs Ford Focus
Family hatchbacks

SEAT Leon vs Volkswagen Golf vs Ford Focus

The Ford Focus, Volkswagen Golf and SEAT Leon are all long established hatchbacks - we find out which is best among the latest crop
11 Jul 2020
New Peugeot 3008 could morph into a coupe-SUV in 2022
Peugeot 3008

New Peugeot 3008 could morph into a coupe-SUV in 2022

Peugeot’s next-generation 3008 looks set to receive a radical redesign in two years’ time, evolving into a style-focussed coupe-SUV
13 Jul 2020
New Skoda Octavia vRS 2020 ride review
Skoda Octavia vRS Hatchback

New Skoda Octavia vRS 2020 ride review

We get our first taste of 242bhp Skoda Octavia vRS with Skoda tech development boss Christian Strube in the driver’s seat
10 Jul 2020