‘Premium brand cars aren’t necessarily better than cheap cars’

Mike Rutherford thinks the latest Driver Power survey shows some upmarket cars can often struggle to adequately satisfy consumers

Dacia Duster - opinion

Looking to upgrade from a modest, mass-manufactured car for the many to a more exclusive, premium model for the few? Upgrading is a perfectly natural and positive goal, but it’s not necessarily the right one – particularly if you’re the type of driver who considers reliability, running costs, safety and value more important than anything else.

True, some (not all) premium cars wear instantly recognisable, highly desirable badges that, in effect, scream ‘quality, heritage, provenance’ and all that other good, laudable stuff. Among other things, such personal vehicles may (but may not!) assist you in creating a more upmarket image for yourself. They might even impress your neighbours – although I never will understand the point of trying to do that.

Easier to comprehend is this: generally, the most satisfying, dependable and safest vehicles aren’t premium cars. What’s more, such workhorse models often deliver the added bonuses of a) lower pence per mile figures and b) greatest possible overall value.

Who says? For starters, I do. Half of the cars I owned or still own fall into unapologetically modest motor territory – everything from factory-fresh or beaten-up Fiats, Fords, Jeeps and VWs. The other half were/are new or used, premium products from the likes of Audi, BMW, Land Rover and Mercedes. And I can honestly say that it’s these latter, more expensive (to buy, tax, insure, run, service and repair) models that have traditionally been the least reliable and, all things considered, the worst value.

More importantly, the car-buying public is (via the latest Driver Power) more or less confirming the same thing: that some upmarket cars can often struggle to adequately satisfy consumers who, considering what they paid for them, expected more.

Of the top 40 cars, just seven (Lexus RX, BMW i3, Polestar 2, Tesla Model 3, Audi Q3, Lexus UX, Mercedes A-Class) are from premium manufacturers. Put another way, an impressive 82.5 per cent of the 40 most satisfying cars are more affordable, non-premium products.

The fact that the well priced C4 from Citroen (for decades, a car company of the people) took the top spot, while Dacia (the bargain champ of the 2020s) grabbed fourth with its Duster SUV confirms that simple, honest, no-nonsense cars can – and in this case, clearly do – see off allegedly superior products built by companies playing the premium game.

A few of them feature far too heavily at the bottom end of the 75-strong satisfaction league. The Jaguar I-Pace is 65th, the Audi A5 is 71st, the BMW 1 Series 72nd and the Range Rover Evoque 73rd, and therefore in the relegation zone. In important individual departments, the Jag is ranked 74th for value, the Audi 75th for safety, the BMW 75th for engine and gearbox, the Range Rover 75th, and last, in three vital areas: MPG and running costs, reliability, and value. This is harsh. But it’s true.

The public has, thanks to Driver Power, had its say. And at the very least, this handful of British and German premium car manufacturers needs to listen and learn from its mistakes and dramatically rectify them. With immediate effect.

Partnership
Need to sell your car?
Find your best offer from over 5,000+ dealers. It’s that easy.

Do you agree with Mike? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section...

Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Recommended

Best home EV chargers 2023
Best home EV charger 2023 - header
Product group tests

Best home EV chargers 2023

We test the top ways to charge your electric or plug-in hybrid car at home
18 Jul 2023
Top 10 most reliable small cars to buy 2023
Most reliable small cars - header
Best cars & vans

Top 10 most reliable small cars to buy 2023

We reveal the most reliable small cars you can buy according to the 2023 Driver Power survey…
17 Jul 2023
Top 10 most reliable 4x4s and SUVs to buy 2023
Most reliable 4x4s and SUVs header
Best cars & vans

Top 10 most reliable 4x4s and SUVs to buy 2023

We reveal the most reliable 4x4s and SUVs you can buy according to the 2023 Driver Power survey…
12 Jul 2023
Top 10 most reliable family cars to buy 2023
Most reliable family cars 2023
Best cars & vans

Top 10 most reliable family cars to buy 2023

We reveal the most reliable family cars you can buy according to the 2023 Driver Power survey
6 Jul 2023

Most Popular

New 2024 Dacia Duster: third generation of Europe’s best-selling SUV revealed
Dacia Duster - front
News

New 2024 Dacia Duster: third generation of Europe’s best-selling SUV revealed

Dacia has taken the wraps off the latest Duster, which arrives with a new look and fresh technology
29 Nov 2023
New Renault Scenic 2023 review: the famous nameplate returns in style
Renault Scenic - front
Road tests

New Renault Scenic 2023 review: the famous nameplate returns in style

We get behind the wheel of new all-electric Renault Scenic to see what all the fuss is about
27 Nov 2023
“Renault is taking over as the manufacturer of cars for the people”
Opinion - Renault Twingo
Opinion

“Renault is taking over as the manufacturer of cars for the people”

Mike Rutherford thinks Renault is doing more than any other manufacturer when it comes to making affordable electric cars
26 Nov 2023