Used BMW 1 Series review
Our BMW 1 Series buyer’s guide has everything you need to know about the 1 Series Mk1 (2004-2011) and 1 Series Mk2 (2011-2019)
The BMW 1 Series arrived in 2004 - yes, it really was that long ago - and followed the 3 Series Compact model. Along with the Audi A3, Mercedes A-Class and VW Golf, it's part of the German domination of the family hatchback market in the past few decades.
It can be considered BMW's entry-model and the 1 Series has always been known as the driver's choice in the market. Compared to the others mentioned above, it's much more fun to drive, especially because until recently, it used rear-wheel drive. This layout tends to make cars feel more agile and it was certainly appealing in first- and second-generation 1 Series models.
Even though the latest third-gen models switched to front-wheel drive, the driver appeal remains. Yet if you want a great-driving hatchback that's also practical and comfortable, a second-hand older model is a great choice.
The second-generation model in particular is becoming a cult car, with enthusiasts flocking to them for their delightful handling and brilliant engines, which have been watered-down for the newer model.
It's not all about the handling, as the BMW is very much a part of the premium car maker's main stable, so it has good build quality and an upmarket interior that will appeal to plenty of other drivers. There's not a huge amount of space in the back seats, but the 1 Series makes loads of sense for those who only expect to carry two people most of the time, or who have smaller children.
Entry-level models are best avoided. Go for an ES or SE, and you’ll have an entertaining, well equipped and frugal small hatch. When BMW launched its original 1 Series in 2004 it wasn’t the most cohesive design, but it became a big seller. Buyers were wooed by the badge, while a wide range of engines and bodystyles meant there was something for everyone.
Car group tests
The second generation, introduced in 2011, still had plenty of engines and trims but just one bodystyle – a hatchback, with the coupe and convertible moved to the new 2 Series range. Now available from under £5,000 at dealers, the 1 Series Mk2 can make a great used buy, depending on your needs.
- BMW 1 Series Mk1 (2004-2011) - Original version of premium small hatch is becoming a used bargain.
- BMW 1 Series Mk2 (2011-2019) – Latest BMW premium hatch can be a great buy.
BMW 1 Series Mk2
Codenamed F20/F21 by BMW, the 1 Series Mk2 made its debut in September 2011 in 116i, 118i, 116d, 118d and 120d forms. At first there was only a five-door hatch, but a three-door appeared in May 2012, three months after the arrival of 125i, 125d and 99g/km 116d EfficientDynamics options.
May 2012 saw the launch of 114i and 320bhp M135i options, then six months later xDrive (4WD) versions of the 120d and M135i went on sale. A 95bhp 1.6-litre 114d came in November 2012. A 136bhp three-cylinder was fitted to the 118i from July 2015, just as a facelifted 1 Series went on sale with new diesel engines and overhauled petrol units. A sizzling 335bhp M140i arrived in June 2016.
Which one should I buy?
Most of the 1 Series available have five doors and a diesel engine; the three-door cars look more stylish but rear seat access is poor. The six-speed manual and eight-speed auto are great, but you’re better off avoiding the basic entry-level ES trim.
SE adds Bluetooth, multimedia and a multifunction steering wheel. Sport and Urban versions feature 17-inch alloys and sportier detailing, while Urban gets part-leather trim. The 1 Series has an extensive options list, so equipment levels can vary.
BMW 1 Series Mk2 reviews
- BMW 1 Series in-depth review
- BMW 1 Seres xDrive review
- BMW 1 Series Sport review
- BMW 116d EfficentDynamics review
- BMW 125i M Sport review
- BMW M135i reviewBMW M140i review
Alternatives to the BMW 1 Series Mk2
The Audi A3 launched the premium small hatch sector and it’s the BMW’s biggest rival thanks to the wide model choice, smart styling and excellent cabin. It’s just not as good to drive.
You could say similar about the VW Golf, which is closely related to the Audi, but unlike the A3, doesn’t come with a four-wheel-drive option in regular hatchback form. The third-generation Mercedes A-Class is more mainstream than its predecessors, has sold in bigger numbers and is better to drive. Volvo’s V40 is also worth a look and don’t ignore the Ford Focus – it may be much cheaper, but it’s still a great car.
What to look for:
Check for leaves blocking the drains in the bulkhead; once a blockage occurs, water is likely to get into the electrics, causing damage.
The headlights are prone to misting up, but as they’re ventilated, any moisture behind the glass should find its way out, eventually.
The front doors can rattle. Lubricating the door seals can help, but usually a visit to the dealer for a strip down is the only solution.
Several 1 Series models have suffered from knocking noises from the rear suspension, because of faulty dampers and/or mounting bushes.
The design is sober, although the solid build and dash clarity are beyond reproach – especially on cars with the iDrive cabin control system. Rear seat space is a little tight and shallow windows hit visibility but boot capacity (360 litres with the seats up and 1,200 litres if they’re folded) is okay.
Check out the latest used BMW 1 Series prices on our sister site BuyaCar.
All 1 Series have condition-based, variable servicing, so the car flags up when attention is needed. The system reviews the condition of a wide range of service items, but only those that need replacing will be renewed, so service costs are never the same. Services are typically due every 18,000 to 20,000 miles or two years; a minor check costs around £200, with a major one around £350.
The coolant never needs replacing, and as the engines are chain-driven, no new cambelts are needed, but the brake fluid should be renewed every two years (£100).
The 1 Series Mk2 has been recalled nine times. The first was in July 2013; cars built between February and June could suffer a loss of drive due to clutch failure.
In June 2015 came the next recall, for models made between September 2013 and March 2015. It centred on fuel pump failure due to a problem that could lead to the car either not starting or cutting out. The next recall was in December 2016 for examples made up to December 2015 that could suffer electric power steering failure.
Other recalls in 2017 and 2018 covered issues regarding the driveshaft, the electrics, a seat backrest and exhaust gas recirculation module.
Driver Power owner satisfaction
The 1 Series finished 41st in our Driver Power 2017 satisfaction survey, which isn’t bad for a six-year-old car. However the latest data from 2020 didn't feature the car in the top 75 at all.
As the only rear-wheel-drive model in the segment, the 1 Series is great to drive. It’s also safe, beautifully built and comes with a big choice of efficient engines, so you’re not sacrificing performance in the quest for economy. But it’s not exclusive as there is one around every corner. Despite its ubiquity, the 1 Series isn’t the greatest bargain around thanks to high prices when new, while steep running costs mean this isn’t a car to buy if you’re on a budget. The 1 Series is a premium product and while it’s not the best for value in this class, there’s still plenty to like about it.