MINI vs MINI
MINI Traveller V MINI Clubman Cooper S
THE question of whether the new MINI can be compared to the original has been debated many times. However, just as the flames of controversy were beginning to die down, BMW threw a few gallons of unleaded on to the fire with the release of the Clubman.
Having already upset the purists by mixing up historical names (the estates were originally called Traveller and Countryman, not Clubman), has MINI gone a step too far with its estate?
Launched in 1961, the Morris Mini Traveller (and its sister car, the Austin Mini Countryman) was introduced in an effort to broaden the Mini’s customer base. The British Motor Corporation was also keen on lifting production numbers up to a point where it could begin to see a return on its investment.
The Traveller is an exquisite piece of design. Our version – a mint 1967 model owned my Mini fanatic Boyce Wheal from Stourport on Severn, Worcestershire – displays why the original stirs up such strong emotions. The packaging is also stunning. Not only is there room for a six-footer behind the wheel, there’s plenty of space in the back, too.
Despite being bigger, faster and better kitted out than its predecessor, the new version demonstrates that recreating the past is sometimes trickier than doing something new. Thanks to the legislation surrounding car design these days, features such as the Clubman’s rear doors – which incorporate cut-outs to allow the tail-lights to be seen at all times – are far more complex pieces of engineering than they needed to be in the Traveller’s day.
There’s one comparison the original will never win, though. The Mini didn’t return a penny in profit for its maker in 40 years. The new MINI, on the other hand, is one of the most profitable small cars in the business. Had BMC got its sums right, who knows what the British motor industry would look like now…
Facts and figures
MINI Traveller / MINI Clubman Cooper S
Price new: £635 (1967) / £16,860Engine: 848cc 4cyl / 1,598cc 4cylTransmission: Four-speed manual, front-wheel drive / Six-speed front-wheel drivePower: 34bhp / 175bhpLength/width/height: 3,299/1,410/1,359mm / 3,958/1,683/1,432mm
In this review
- 1IntroductionWe bring 10 motoring classics head-to-head with their brand new equivalents to see which are the greatest...
- 2Mercedes vs MercedesMercedes C63 AMG vs Mercedes 190E Cosworth
- 3Volvo vs VolvoVolvo C30 2.0 R Design Sport vs Volvo 480 ES
- 4Skyline vs GT-RNissan Skyline R32 vs Nissan GT-R Premium
- 5Panda vs PandaFiat Panda 4x4 Cross vs Fiat Panda 4x4
- 6Ibiza vs IbizaSEAT Ibiza MkI vs SEAT Ibiza 1.2
- 7Fiesta vs FiestaFord Fiesta Mki vs Ford Fiesta 1.4 Zetec
- 8Scirocco vs SciroccoVolkswagen Scirocco 1.4 TSI vs Volkswagen Scirocco 1.5
- 9Astra vs AstraVauxhall Astra VXR vs Vauxhall Astra GTE
- 10500 vs 500Fiat 500L vs Fiat 500 1.3 Multijet Lounge
- 11MINI vs MINI - currently readingMINI Traveller V MINI Clubman Cooper S
- 12Lambo vs LamboLamborghini Gallardo LP560-4 V Lamborghini Countach 25th Anniversary
- 13Facts and figures