Executive Car of the Year 2017: BMW 5 Series

The BMW 5 Series is the 2017 Auto Express Executive Car of the Year, with the Mercedes E-Class and Tesla Model S commended

Things move quickly in the executive market. The all-new 5 Series has reclaimed its crown as the class champ thanks to its winning blend of style, refinement and technology. 

Based on a new platform, the BMW adopts much of the technology from the larger and more expensive 7 Series, but packages it into a cheaper proposition, while offering a much more involving drive at the same time.

Among the 5 Series’ talents are a new auto parking system that allows the saloon to be moved in and out of tight spaces using an optional digital key fob. A new Driving Assistant Plus pack also lets the car accelerate, brake and steer itself on the motorway at speeds of up to 130mph. It will even change lanes and overtake, proving just how advanced this BMW is.

Refinement has also taken a leap forward with the latest model, with a range of smooth engines and a supremely cosseting ride. Go for adaptive dampers and the breadth of ability is widened further still, offering a supple, flowing ride in Comfort mode.

The 5 Series retains its excellent driving dynamics. Ramp the dampers up to Sport and the sharp turn-in, strong body control and impressive grip make this a sporting executive saloon. The new platform has helped trim around 100kg from the seventh-generation model, which goes some way into making it one of the most nimble and engaging executive cars on sale.

BMW 5 Series - rear

Four and six-cylinder petrol and diesel engines are available, while xDrive four-wheel drive is offered on selected models. All cars get an eight-speed gearbox, which changes smoothly in auto and snaps through ratios quickly in manual mode. Allied to the 187bhp 2.0-litre diesel, the powertrain serves up decent performance, excellent refinement and impressive running costs, with a claimed 68.8mpg. The BMW doesn’t skimp on luxury, either, with a full leather interior, sat-nav and digital instruments as standard.  

Our choice

BMW 520d SE (£36,165) 

Only SE and M Sport trims are offered in the 5 Series line-up; racier M Sport models bring a beefier bodykit and extra equipment, but cost a further £3,020. So it’s the entry-level SE version we’d go for, as this gets the same impressive and intuitive infotainment system, a digital dash and just as much comfort, agility and quality. The 2.0 diesel engine also offers the best balance of performance and economy. 

Commended

Mercedes E-Class

Mercedes E-Class - front

If a sophisticated driving experience and plenty of luxury is what you’re after then the Mercedes E-Class has it in spades. It lacks the 5 Series’ overall engagement and excitement, but makes up for it with a beautifully crafted cabin, impressive digital displays and air suspension, even if they’re optional extras.

Tesla Model S

Tesla Model S - front

Tesla’s assault on the mainstream manufacturers continues as subtle updates to the Model S make it a genuine alternative in the executive class. It might be on the pricey side and quality leaves a little to be desired in some areas, but nothing else like it offers such a mix of astonishing performance and rock-bottom running costs. This is a genuinely viable executive EV.

Auto Express New Car Awards 2017

For complete, in-depth coverage of the 2017 New Car Awards, buy your collector's edition copy of the Auto Express magazine now or click here to subscribe...

Recommended

Tesla Model S Plaid claims Nurbugring lap record for a production EV
Tesla Model S facelift - front
Tesla Model S

Tesla Model S Plaid claims Nurbugring lap record for a production EV

Tesla founder Elon Musk claims “unmodified” high-performance Model S saloon has set a 7min 31sec lap time around the ‘ring
10 Sep 2021
Best used executive cars
Best used executive cars - header
Best cars & vans

Best used executive cars

If you need a fast, comfortable and stylish set of wheels, check out the best used executive cars the market has to offer
18 Aug 2021
Top 10 longest range electric cars 2021
Longest electric ranges - header
Electric cars

Top 10 longest range electric cars 2021

EV range is a hot topic right now so we’ve listed the top 10 electric cars with the longest range
12 Aug 2021
Best plug-in hybrids 2021
Best PHEV cars
Electric cars

Best plug-in hybrids 2021

The plug-in hybrid market has grown exponentially in recent years. Here are our top 10 electrified favourites.
4 Aug 2021

Most Popular

'The death of cheap cars will be a travesty for personal mobility'
Opinion cheap cars
Opinion

'The death of cheap cars will be a travesty for personal mobility'

Our appetite for small, cheap cars is as strong as ever - although Mike Rutherford warns they may no longer be profitable
12 Sep 2021
New Toyota RAV4 Adventure heads up 2022 model refresh
Toyota RAV4 Adventure
News

New Toyota RAV4 Adventure heads up 2022 model refresh

The rugged Toyota RAV4 Adventure targets lifestyle buyers with a tough-looking new front bumper and interior tweaks
14 Sep 2021
E10 petrol explained: UK prices, checker tool and is it OK for your car?
Petrol pump
News

E10 petrol explained: UK prices, checker tool and is it OK for your car?

E10 petrol is up to 10 per cent ethanol and is available at UK fuel stations now as part of the bid to cut CO2 emissions
1 Sep 2021