Subaru XV vs Kia Sportage
Crossovers are big news in the UK, so we see if the new Subaru XV can beat the class-leading Kia Sportage
Does the world need another compact crossover? Subaru thinks so – and believes its new XV can offer something genuinely different in this class.
Balancing the brand’s core strengths while attracting a whole new audience is no easy task, but the XV has the right attributes. It features Subaru’s trademark all-wheel-drive hardware and flat-four engines, yet has a brave new look, the promise of low emissions and improved quality.
Subaru expects the XV to be its best-selling model by the middle of next year, so the pressure is on. Here we test the boxer diesel, which will account for two-thirds of sales.
We could have picked any number of rivals, but to test the XV’s mettle we’ve lined it up against a current favourite: the Kia Sportage. In desirable KX-3 trim this stylish car has permanent four-wheel drive, a punchy 2.0-litre diesel and is packed with kit. It should be a close contest.
Verdict
Breaking into this class is tougher than ever given the sheer number of talented crossovers on the market. Subaru has made a bold effort to offer something different from the norm with the XV, but in doing so, it has misjudged what small SUV buyers are looking for.
More reviews
Car group tests
- Abarth Punto vs Corsa SRi
- Mercedes GLA vs Alfa Romeo Tonale 2024 twin test: premium plug-in hybrids go head-to-head
- Alpina XD3 Biturbo vs Porsche Macan S Diesel
- The best long-term car tests 2022
- Ariel Nomad
- Aston Martin Vantage vs Porsche 911 GTS
- Audi RS and performance mega test: historic Audi sports cars head-to-head
- BMW 5 Series vs Audi A6 vs Volvo S90
- Audi S3 vs Mercedes-AMG A 35
- Range Rover vs Bentley Bentayga: 2022 twin test review
In-depth reviews
- Abarth 124 Spider review
- Abarth Punto (2008-2015)
- Alfa Romeo Tonale review
- Alfa Romeo Stelvio review
- Alfa Romeo Giulia review
Long-term tests
- Alfa Romeo Tonale PHEV long-term test: things are looking bright thanks to our stylish SUV
- Alpine A110 GT: long term test
- BMW iX xDrive50 long-term test: not a looker, but great in every other way
- BYD Atto 3 Design long-term test: a great first effort
- Cupra Formentor VZN long-term test: a fun but thirsty family car
- Cupra Born V3: long-term test review
- DS 4 E-Tense 225: long-term test review
- Fiat 500: long-term test review
- Genesis Electrified GV70 long-term test: all-season tyres reinvent our luxurious EV
- Jaguar F-Pace PHEV: long-term test review
Reviews
Road tests
- New AC Cobra 378 Superblower 2021 review
- New AC Cobra 378 review
- New Alfa Romeo Stelvio 2023 review
- New Alfa Romeo Giulia 2023 review
- New Alpina B3 Touring 2023 review
- New Alpine A290 prototype review: electric hot hatch shows plenty of promise
- Alpine A110 R 2024 review: almost the perfect sports car
- New Alpine A110 S 2022 review
- New Alpine A110 Legende GT 2021 review
Used car tests
- Used Alpine A110 (2017-date) review
- Used Audi A7 (Mk2, 2018-date) review: a classy and comfortable motorway cruiser
- Used Bentley Continental GT (Mk3, 2018-date) review
- Used Dacia Duster (Mk2, 2018-date) review
- Used Ford Kuga Mk3 (2020-date) review: a popular and desirable mid-size SUV
- Used Ford Puma (2020-date) review: an impressive SUV that’s great to drive
- Used Honda e (Mk1, 2020-date) review: limited range, but a desirable city EV
- Used Hyundai i10 (Mk3, 2020-date) review: one of the very best city cars
- Used SsangYong Rexton (Mk2, 2017-date) review
- Used SsangYong Tivoli review
The car lacks the badge kudos of an Audi Q3, the off-road reputation of a Land Rover Freelander 2 or the keen value for money of the Sportage. While the XV is priced to compete with all of these cars, it beats none of them.
You can sense the depth of engineering beneath the Subaru’s chunky bodywork, and the entertaining driving experience is what we’ve come to expect from the brand. But the dated cabin will be enough to deter most buyers before they’ve even taken a test drive. That’s a shame, because the new aftersales package shows that Subaru is trying hard to compete with rivals’ long warranties – although it’s still not enough to tip the scales in the XV’s favour.
The Kia Sportage is one of the best crossovers around and comfortably beats the Subaru in this contest. It can do pretty much everything the XV can do over rough terrain, but is quieter, more comfortable and much more refined. Best of all, it’s cheaper and better equipped than the Subaru.
Winner
Kia Sportage ★★★★
Another victory for the Kia – and proof that Japanese manufacturers need to take notes from their Korean counterparts. The Sportage feels like a quality product inside and out. It doesn’t match the XV for raw driver appeal, but its softer set-up and greater practicality make for a more rounded family car. The fact that it’s £1,670 cheaper and has stronger residuals widens the winning margin.
2nd
Subaru XV ★★
The XV has its charms. It’s well engineered, good to drive and highly capable off-road, but there are some glaring issues that are hard to ignore. Subaru seems to have wilfully ignored what buyers in this market want, and the hugely disappointing cabin, stiff ride and lack of refinement outweigh the positives. The high price and heavy depreciation mean it’s for committed Subaru fans only.