Volvo V60 vs rivals
Is Volvo’s new V60 top of the estate car tree? We get festive and load it up against three rivals to find out.
Christmas has come early for estate car buyers! With a few weeks to go before the festive season gets into full swing, Volvo has ripped the wrapping paper off its new V60 load carrier.
Designed to tackle the cream of the compact estate car crop head on, the Swedish newcomer aims to mix eye-catching looks with family-friendly load-carrying practicality. Bosses also claim the V60 will be great to drive, thanks to suspension that has been fine-tuned for British roads.
We test the car in top-of-the-range SE Lux Premium trim, with the firm’s punchy 161bhp 2.0-litre five-cylinder engine. On sale for £30,010, it faces formidable competition from a trio of versatile German machines.
Volvo’s engineers used the sporty BMW 3-Series Touring as a handling benchmark for the V60, yet the Mercedes C-Class estate sets the standard for space and practicality. Finally, the sleek Audi A4 Avant serves up a desirable blend of fashionable good looks, an upmarket cabin and a spacious boot. All three models have a rock-solid image that means they’re as comfortable on the school run as they are in the corporate car park.
It’s a big ask for the V60.
So, will the newcomer wrap up an impressive victory?
Verdict
Strip away the style, premium badging and sporty driving dynamics, and our contenders are all trying to do the same thing. With large load bays and flexible cabins, they’re surefire family favourites – but we think the Volvo sacrifices too much versatility for its stylish good looks.
More reviews
Car group tests
- Abarth Punto vs Corsa SRi
- Mercedes GLA vs Alfa Romeo Tonale 2024 twin test: premium plug-in hybrids go head-to-head
- Alpina XD3 Biturbo vs Porsche Macan S Diesel
- The best long-term car tests 2022
- Ariel Nomad
- Audi S3 vs BMW M135: which German brand builds the hottest hatchback?
- Volkswagen Touareg vs Audi Q8: an SUV sibling rivalry
- Range Rover vs Bentley Bentayga: 2022 twin test review
- BMW 128ti vs Volkswagen Golf GTI: understated hot hatches have plenty of used appeal
- Morgan Plus Four vs BMW Z4: retro-modern roadster battle
In-depth reviews
- Abarth 600e review
- Abarth 124 Spider review
- Abarth Punto (2008-2015)
- Alfa Romeo Tonale review
- Alfa Romeo Stelvio review
Long-term tests
- Alfa Romeo Tonale PHEV long-term test: things are looking bright thanks to our stylish SUV
- Alpine A110 GT: long term test
- BYD Dolphin Design long-term test: compact EV is a near-perfect family runaround
- DS 4 E-Tense 225: long-term test review
- Fiat 500: long-term test review
- Genesis GV60 Premium long-term test: wireless Apple CarPlay is a surprising omission
- Genesis Electrified GV70 long-term test: great for a family road trip
- New Honda e:Ny1 Advance long-term test: poor efficiency dents EV’s appeal
- Jaguar F-Pace PHEV: long-term test review
- Jeep Avenger Summit long-term test: a good all-round electric SUV
Road tests
- New AC Cobra 378 Superblower 2021 review
- New AC Cobra 378 review
- New Alfa Romeo Stelvio 2023 review
- New Alfa Romeo Giulia 2023 review
- New Alpina B3 Touring 2023 review
- Alpine A110 R 2024 review: almost the perfect sports car
- New Alpine A110 S 2022 review
- New Alpine A110 Legende GT 2021 review
- New Aston Martin DBX707 2024 review: updated interior transforms Aston’s super-SUV
- New Aston Martin Vantage 2024 review: Britain's answer to the Porsche 911 Turbo
Used car tests
- Used Alpine A110 (2017-date) review
- Used Audi A6 (Mk5, 2018-date) buyer’s guide: classy exec is a great family car
- Used Bentley Continental GT (Mk3, 2018-date) review
- Used BMW Z4 (Mk3, 2019-date) buyer’s guide: a worthy Porsche Boxster rival
- Used Cupra Formentor (Mk1, 2020-date) buyer's guide: stylish and family-friendly
- Used Dacia Sandero (Mk3, 2020-date) review: all the essentials at a low price
- Used Ford Mustang Mach-E (Mk1, 2020-date) buyer's guide: a sporty EV with decent range
- Used Honda Jazz (MK4, 2020-date) review: a reliable supermini with plenty of space
- Used Honda e (Mk1, 2020-2024) review: limited range, but a desirable city EV
- Used Hyundai i20 (Mk3, 2020-date) review: a classy and appealing supermini?
Given the firm’s heritage, the V60’s mediocre carrying capacity is disappointing. Its eye-catching looks, long list of standard kit and relaxing comfort will be enough to attract some, but it finishes fourth in this test, just behind the Audi.
The stylish A4 Avant is well equipped and spacious, but is let down by its high price, below-par performance and uncompromising S line suspension set-up.
That leaves Mercedes and BMW to fight it out. Keen drivers will love the 320d’s dynamics and punchy performance, while low running costs make it a sound financial choice. But there’s no escaping its relatively small and poorly shaped boot.
This is where the Merc excels. Not only is it easily the best estate car, it’s top in terms of pace and close to the BMW for driver fun.
1. Merc C250 CDI Sport
The C-Class is the most practical choice. It’s also the priciest, but strong residuals should offset this, and the 168bhp C220 CDI costs even less.
2. BMW 320d M Sport
IF you’re after fun, the BMW should be top of your shopping list. It’s also cost effective, thanks to low CO2 emissions – it’s the best company car buy.
3. Audi A4 Avant 2.0 TDI
Sleek Audi rivals the Volvo for kerb appeal, and its beautifully built and spacious cabin is one
of the best in the business. High price and jarring ride let it down.
4. Volvo V60 D3
Volvo's estate has eye-catching looks and bags of refinement and comfort. But there’s no ignoring its small boot, uninvolving driving dynamics and poor fuel returns.